Skip to content

History

14 min left
CHECKED · HISTORY

Alexander the Great: What the Ancient Sources Say About 10 Famous Stories

Ten familiar stories about him, set beside Arrian, Plutarch, Diodorus and modern historians.

Hacks Vitae artwork (AI-assisted)
The answer

The sources back some famous stories, such as Aristotle teaching him and a city named after his horse.

The knot, the fire at Persepolis and his death were already disputed by the writers we depend on, and they said so. In Plutarch he wept because he had not yet become lord of a single world, not because none were left.

Why it mattersThe popular versions keep the drama and drop the doubts the ancient writers wrote down.

Our verdicts
  • 2Doesn't hold up
  • 2Partly
  • 2Holds up
  • 4Still argued

See every verdict →

By Hacks Vitae Published Updated Last checked October 2026 14 min read 18 sources ↓

Start hereAlexander is remembered for cutting the Gordian knot with one stroke of his sword. Yet Arrian gives two versions of how he did it, and says he cannot affirm with confidence which happened. So which famous stories does the record support?

Alexander III of Macedon, remembered as Alexander the Great, lived from 356 to 323 BC. He reigned for twelve years and eight months, by Arrian’s count. In that time he took over the Persian Empire and marched into India.

He is also the subject of a great many confident stories. Here are ten of the most familiar, and what the ancient historians and the modern scholars who read them say about each.

The verdicts

01 Aristotle was Alexander's teacherCredited to Popular story Holds up Plutarch says Philip sent for Aristotle; the teaching probably lasted only two or three years. Evidence ↓
02 He cut the Gordian knot with his swordCredited to Popular story Still argued Arrian gives the sword and Aristobulus's pulled pin, then says he cannot affirm which happened. Evidence ↓
03 He was never defeated in battleCredited to Popular story Partly Unbeaten in four great battles; checked at the Persian Gates and Hyphasis; a detachment lost at the Polytimetus. Evidence ↓
04 He burned Persepolis in a drunken partyCredited to Popular story Still argued Arrian describes planned revenge; Plutarch, Diodorus and Curtius a drinking party. The ruins lean toward a planned burning. Evidence ↓
05 He named a city after his horseCredited to Popular story Holds up Arrian and Plutarch both record Bucephala on the Hydaspes; they differ on how the horse died. Evidence ↓
06 He conquered the known worldCredited to Popular story Doesn't hold up Briant says it restored the empire to Darius I's limits; in India he turned back at the Hyphasis. Evidence ↓
07 He wept because there were no more worlds to conquerCredited to Popular saying Doesn't hold up In Plutarch he wept because he had not yet become lord of a single world. Evidence ↓
08 He set out to spread Greek culture across his empireCredited to Popular story Still argued Greek culture spread; whether he planned it is argued. Briant sees responses to the demands of the hour. Evidence ↓
09 Alexander was poisonedCredited to Popular story Still argued The reported court diary describes a fever; poison was suspected only later, Plutarch says. Cause unknown. Evidence ↓
10 His empire fell apart the moment he diedCredited to Popular story Partly It broke up over years; Antigonus took the title of king only in 307/6 BC. Evidence ↓
6 of 10 shown · a mix of every verdict

A short life

Becoming king. Alexander became king of Macedon in 336 BC, when his father, Philip II, was murdered.

The war with Persia. The main Macedonian army crossed into Asia in 334. In May of that year he won his first pitched battle, at the Granicus river. He defeated the Persian king, Darius III, at Issus in November 333. He beat him again at Gaugamela on 1 October 331, and took over the vast Persian treasure.

In July 330 Darius was murdered in a plot led by Bessus, the satrap, or provincial governor, of Bactria.

Into India. Three years of heavy fighting in Bactria and Sogdiana followed. In the spring of 326 he won the battle of the Hydaspes, in India. There his soldiers, weary of campaigning, made him turn back.

Death. He died in Babylon in 323 BC. He was in the eighth month of his thirty-third year, according to Aristobulus, whom Arrian follows. Even the length of his reign varies by source: twelve years and eight months in Arrian, twelve years and seven months in Diodorus.

Thebes and Tyre. The campaigns cost many lives, and the ancient writers record the worst of it plainly. Early in his reign Thebes revolted, stirred up by exiles returning to the city. They claimed that Alexander had been killed in Illyria.

When the city was taken, Alexander left its fate to the allies who had fought with him. They decided to raze it to the ground and sell its people into slavery. Priests were exempt, and so were those with ties to the Macedonian kings. Alexander, it is said, also spared the house and descendants of the poet Pindar.

Plutarch gives more than 6,000 killed and more than 30,000 sold. Diodorus gives over 6,000 dead and more than 30,000 captured.

Tyre held out against him for seven months in 332, and there the numbers differ more between sources.

What the sources can and can’t tell us

The histories written by men who marched with Alexander are lost. Arrian built his account mainly on two of them. One was by Ptolemy, a general who later became king of Egypt. The other was by Aristobulus, who also served on the campaign. Not even the titles of their books have survived.

The full narratives we have were all written long afterwards.

The ancient writers knew they were sifting stories. Arrian trusted Aristobulus because he had served on the expedition. He trusted Ptolemy partly because Ptolemy later became a king, and falsifying facts would have disgraced a king more.

Plutarch lists the writers who tell of a visit from the queen of the Amazons, and the others who say it is a fiction. Curtius admits that he reported more than he believed. So when the ancient writers disagree, or a story appears only in the most colourful accounts, it deserves less confidence.

Some stories are told by several writers and still cannot be confirmed. Take his meeting with Diogenes, who asked him to stand out of his light. It is told by Cicero, Plutarch, Arrian and Diogenes Laertius, and whether it happened, nobody can say. We look at it in Diogenes and the Cynics: The Famous Stories, Checked.

Even his title comes from later. The earliest surviving use of the Great for him is in a Roman comedy, Plautus’s Mostellaria, from around 200 BC.

In our translation, a character there boasts that Alexander the Great and Agathocles, as people say, did two very great deeds. The Latin reads Alexandrum magnum atque Agathoclem. That is the earliest use we have, not proof that nobody said it sooner.

Diodorus of SicilyCame to Rome in the middle of the 1st century BC; his Book 17, Badian judges, was probably based on the novel-like work of Cleitarchus
Quintus Curtius RufusProbably wrote in the 1st century AD; the only surviving Latin book devoted to Alexander
PlutarchLived from about AD 45 to 120; warned that he was writing Lives, not Histories
ArrianMade governor of Cappadocia by Hadrian in AD 131; built his Anabasis mainly on Ptolemy and Aristobulus

The histories by men who marched with him are lost; these full narratives were all written long afterwards.

Table 1The four connected accounts, and how late they areGraphic: Hacks Vitae, from the figures in this article.
Holds up

“Aristotle was his teacher”

Credited to Popular story

Holds up The record supports this one, though the teaching was probably short. Plutarch says Philip sent for Aristotle, then the most famous and learned of philosophers. Philip gave teacher and pupil a place to work: the precinct of the nymphs near Mieza.

In 343 BC, at Philip’s request, Aristotle came to the Macedonian capital to teach the king’s thirteen-year-old son.

How much the teaching shaped the pupil is harder to say. Little is known for certain about their time together. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy concludes that some teaching took place, but that it lasted only two or three years. It adds that a longer association, of up to eight years, cannot be ruled out decisively.

↑ All verdicts
Still argued

“He cut the Gordian knot with his sword”

Credited to Popular story

Still argued The ancient writers tell two versions of how he did it. The sword version is the one people remember.

At Gordium, Plutarch says, Alexander saw a famous wagon tied fast to its yoke. Whoever untied it, the story went, would become ruler of Asia in Arrian’s telling, or king of the whole world in Plutarch’s.

Arrian gives the sword version first, as something some people say: Alexander cut through the cord with his sword. Then he adds another. Aristobulus says he pulled out the pin of the wagon-pole instead, a wooden peg that ran through it and held the cord together.

Arrian then declines to choose: “How Alexander performed the feat in connection with this cord, I cannot affirm with confidence”. Plutarch says most writers tell the sword version, and he too credits the pin version to Aristobulus.

Either way the solution is a sideways one. Only the swordstroke is uncertain. We look at the knot as a thinking tool in Mental Models from History.

↑ All verdicts
Partly

“He was never defeated in battle”

Credited to Popular story

Partly His record in the great battles is real, so the claim starts from something true. None of the four great pitched battles went against him: the Granicus in 334, Issus in 333, Gaugamela in 331 and the Hydaspes in 326. But the same sources record three setbacks.

  • The Persian Gates, 330 BC. On the road to Persepolis, the satrap Ariobarzanes blocked a mountain pass with a wall. Alexander’s first attack failed. Many of his men were wounded, Arrian says, and he retreated to his camp. He got through only by leading a force round the pass by night.

  • The river Polytimetus, in Sogdiana. A force he had sent out under Pharnuches was trapped at a river crossing. In Arrian’s account, all but a few were killed with arrows. Alexander himself was not there.

  • The Hyphasis, in India. Here the check came from his own men. The army refused to advance, and the soldiers made him agree to stop.

So he was unbeaten in his great battles, but not unchecked.

↑ All verdicts
Still argued

“He burned Persepolis in a drunken party”

Credited to Popular story

Still argued The palace at Persepolis was burned in the spring of 330 BC. The ancient writers tell two stories about why. The party version is the more colourful of the two, with a torch, revellers and an Athenian woman urging them on.

A planned act. Arrian describes a decision. Alexander burned the palace although Parmenio advised him to spare it. He said he wanted revenge on the Persians for the invasion of Greece, when they burned Athens and its temples.

Arrian himself did not approve. He thought Alexander had not acted wisely. He adds that when Alexander passed that way again, on his return from India, Alexander himself did not approve of it.

A drinking party. Plutarch, Diodorus and Curtius describe a drinking party. An Athenian woman, Thaïs, urged them to set fire to the house of Xerxes, who had burned Athens. Alexander led the revellers there with a torch. Curtius adds that Thaïs was drunk herself: et ipsa temulenta.

Plutarch reports both versions: “This is the way the deed was done, according to some writers; but others say it was premeditated”. On one point, he says, they agree: Alexander quickly regretted it and ordered the fire put out.

The ruins. The ancient writers do not settle it, but the ruins add evidence they did not have. Alireza Shapur Shahbazi, writing in the Encyclopaedia Iranica, concludes that “the fire was deliberate”. He gives two reasons.

  • The precious-metal fittings on the carved reliefs were systematically removed first.
  • No one tried to put out the fire with water from the moat.

That leans toward Arrian’s version of a planned burning. Whether a drinking party was also the occasion is still argued, and the two need not exclude each other.

↑ All verdicts
Holds up

“He named a city after his horse”

Credited to Popular story

Holds up Arrian and Plutarch both record it, and both put the city on the Hydaspes.

After the battle of the Hydaspes, Arrian says, Alexander founded two cities. He named one Nicaea, for his victory, and the other Bucephala, in memory of his horse Bucephalas. Plutarch agrees that he built a city in the horse’s memory on the banks of the Hydaspes, and calls it Bucephalia.

They differ on how the horse died. Arrian says the horse died at about thirty, not from any wound but from toil and old age. Plutarch says most writers blamed wounds, though Onesicritus, the pilot of Alexander’s ship, said old age.

Plutarch also passes on a story that Alexander named a city after his dog, Peritas. He tells it only as something people say.

↑ All verdicts
Doesn't hold up

“He conquered the known world”

Credited to Popular story

Doesn't hold up His conquests were vast, so the phrase is easy to reach for. But they had edges that the ancient writers knew about.

The historian Pierre Briant sums up the result: the conquest restored the empire to the limits Darius I had given it. In other words, his conquests roughly matched the Persian Empire as it had been under Darius I.

Beyond those limits lay lands that Arrian’s sources talked about. Some said that in his last years Alexander was thinking of sailing round Arabia and Africa to conquer Libya and Carthage. Others said he meant to go to Sicily, because the spreading fame of the Romans made him jealous.

Arrian himself wrote that he could not guess with any certainty what the plans were.

In India he turned back at the Hyphasis. Yet in the speech Arrian gives him there, Alexander says the distance to the Ganges is not great. A planned voyage round Arabia, Briant notes, did not happen.

↑ All verdicts
Doesn't hold up

“He wept because there were no more worlds to conquer”

Credited to Popular saying

Doesn't hold up There is an ancient story of Alexander weeping over worlds, which may be why this one sounds so solid. But it runs the other way.

In Plutarch’s essay On Tranquillity of Mind, Alexander wept when he heard Anaxarchus talk about an infinite number of worlds. When his friends asked what was wrong, he answered with a question, given here in W. C. Helmbold’s 1939 translation.

“Is it not worthy of tears that, when the number of worlds is infinite, we have not yet become lords of a single one?”

Plutarch sets him beside Crates. Crates owned only a bag and a threadbare cloak, yet spent his whole life joking and laughing. In Plutarch, the tears are about wanting more, not about having run out.

↑ All verdicts
Still argued

“He set out to spread Greek culture across his empire”

Credited to Popular story

Still argued Greek language and culture did spread after his conquests, across the Middle East. So it is natural to assume he planned it. Whether that was his aim is still argued.

The case for a plan rests partly on Plutarch. In the Life, he says Alexander picked thirty thousand boys and had them taught Greek and trained to use Macedonian weapons.

In his essay On the Fortune of Alexander, he goes much further. There he says that under Alexander, Homer was widely read, and that Alexander founded more than seventy cities among tribes he calls savage.

The translator, F. C. Babbitt, calls these essays epideictic orations: speeches written for display.

The case against comes from a historian of Persia. Briant points out three things.

On the old idea of a “policy of fusion”, a deliberate blending of Macedonians and Iranians, Briant urges caution. He even calls Alexander, in many ways, the “last of the Achaemenids”, the dynasty of Persian kings he defeated.

The evidence leans toward Briant’s reading, for two reasons that show in the sources.

The argument is about what he intended, not about the spread itself.

↑ All verdicts
Still argued

“He was poisoned”

Credited to Popular story

Still argued One account, said to come from a court journal, describes a fever. The poison story came later, Plutarch says, and even writers who doubted it still passed it on.

A fever. The first story comes from the court journal, the Royal Diary. Arrian and Plutarch both quote it, and Plutarch says most of his account follows it word for word.

It describes a fever that set in after drinking at the house of a friend, Medius, and grew worse over days. Aristobulus, Plutarch adds, says he had a raging fever.

Poison. The second story says poison was sent by Antipater, Alexander’s governor in Europe. In that story, Antipater’s son, the royal cup-bearer, gave it to him. Arrian reports this, but says he records such stories only so as not to seem ignorant of them, not because he believes them.

Plutarch says that at first, no one suspected poison. He adds: “Most writers, however, think that the story of the poisoning is altogether a fabrication”. Diodorus tells of a huge beaker of unmixed wine and a sudden pain. He then gives the poison version as one that some historians tell.

Modern guesses. Modern writers have proposed many causes. A 2014 review lists, among others, old wounds, the effects of alcohol, and malaria, typhoid fever, or some other parasitic or viral illness. Its authors argue only that if the king was poisoned, the plant Veratrum album is a more plausible cause than arsenic, strychnine and other plant poisons.

A 2003 paper suggested West Nile virus, and drew published replies. The 2014 review also notes that the diary was only said to have been kept at the royal court, so the symptoms reach us second-hand. The evidence does not settle the cause, and we do not lean either way.

↑ All verdicts
Partly

“His empire fell apart the moment he died”

Credited to Popular story

Partly It did break up, but over years rather than at once. In Babylon, Diodorus says, the throne was empty, because the king had died leaving no child. His wife Roxana was expecting a child.

The army and generals agreed on a shared arrangement. Alexander’s half-brother Arrhidaeus was made king under the name Philip, and Perdiccas became regent. The leading generals took the provinces and were to obey the king and Perdiccas.

The generals soon fought each other. But for years they did so in the name of Alexander’s family. A treaty of 311/10 BC still named Cassander general of Europe until Alexander’s son by Roxana came of age. Soon afterwards Cassander had the boy and his mother killed.

Only in the Athenian year 307/6 BC did Antigonus put on the royal diadem and call himself king. The other generals, Ptolemy, Seleucus, Lysimachus and Cassander, then called themselves kings too. The separate kingdoms grew out of the wars that followed his death.

↑ All verdicts

Quick answers

Did Alexander the Great cut the Gordian knot?

Arrian gives two versions: he cut through the cord with his sword, or, as Aristobulus says, he pulled out the pin of the wagon-pole. Arrian then says he cannot affirm with confidence which happened.

How did Alexander the Great die?

The cause is not known. One account, said to come from a court journal, describes a fever after drinking; a story that Antipater sent poison came later, Plutarch says, and Arrian records it without believing it. Modern suggestions include malaria and typhoid fever.

Did Alexander the Great conquer the known world?

His conquests were vast but bounded: the historian Pierre Briant says they restored the Persian Empire to the limits Darius I had given it. In India he turned back at the Hyphasis, and Arrian could not guess his later plans with any certainty.

Was Aristotle really Alexander's teacher?

Yes. Plutarch says Philip sent for Aristotle. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy dates his arrival at the Macedonian capital to 343 BC, to teach the thirteen-year-old prince. It concludes the teaching lasted only two or three years, though a longer association cannot be ruled out decisively.

Why is he called Alexander the Great?

The earliest surviving use of "the Great" for him is in a Roman comedy, Plautus's Mostellaria, from around 200 BC. That is the earliest use we have, not proof that nobody said it sooner.

Use this

The lesson

Before you retell a famous story, count the versions the oldest sources give.

The rule

How many versions do the oldest sources give, and did any of them hesitate?

Quick quiz

Three questions, thirty seconds

Nothing is scored or saved. Recalling it once now is what makes it last.

1. What does Arrian say about how Alexander undid the Gordian knot?

Answer: That he cannot affirm with confidence how it was done.Read it again ↑

2. In Plutarch's story, why did Alexander weep?

Answer: Because he had not yet become lord of a single world.Read it again ↑

3. Where is the earliest surviving use of "the Great" for him?

Answer: In a Roman comedy by Plautus, from around 200 BC.Read it again ↑

How we checked this · Last checked October 2026
  • Quotations come from E. J. Chinnock's 1884 translation of Arrian (Project Gutenberg), Bernadotte Perrin's 1919 Loeb translation of Plutarch's Life of Alexander, and the Loeb translations of Diodorus by C. Bradford Welles (Book 17) and Russel M. Geer (Books 18–20), read on LacusCurtius.
  • English from the Latin of Curtius and Plautus is our own.
  • For the 2014 Clinical Toxicology review we read the abstract.
  • The Royal Diary is lost; we know it only from later writers who quote it, Arrian and Plutarch among them, and it was only said to have been kept at court.
  • The page sets out what the record shows, including Thebes and Tyre, and gives no verdict on Alexander himself.

How we check every article →

Sources

Primary written at the time, by a witness, or the original text Scholarly edited or peer-reviewed work Popular press, blogs and general websites
  • Arrian, The Anabasis of Alexander, trans. E. J. Chinnock (Hodder and Stoughton, 1884): preface; 1.7–9; 2.3; 2.24; 3.18; 4.5; 5.19; 5.25–28; 6.30; 7.1; 7.25–28.Primary
  • Plutarch, Life of Alexander, trans. Bernadotte Perrin, Loeb Classical Library vol. VII (1919), via LacusCurtius: chs. 1, 7, 11, 18, 38, 46, 47, 61, 75–77.Primary
  • Plutarch, On Tranquillity of Mind 4, trans. W. C. Helmbold, Loeb Moralia vol. VI (1939), via LacusCurtius.Primary
  • Plutarch, On the Fortune or the Virtue of Alexander I, trans. F. C. Babbitt, Loeb Moralia vol. IV (1936), via LacusCurtius.Primary
  • Diodorus Siculus, Library of History, Book 17 trans. C. Bradford Welles, Books 18–20 trans. Russel M. Geer (Loeb), via LacusCurtius: 17.14, 17.46, 17.72, 17.117–118, 18.2, 19.105, 20.53.Primary
  • Quintus Curtius Rufus, Historiae Alexandri Magni, Latin text via LacusCurtius: 4.4.17, 5.7.3.Primary
  • Plautus, Mostellaria 775, Latin text via The Latin Library.Primary
  • Pierre Briant, “Alexander the Great”, Encyclopaedia Iranica (1985).Scholarly
  • Alireza Shapur Shahbazi, “Persepolis”, Encyclopaedia Iranica (2009, updated 2016).Scholarly
  • Marie Louise Chaumont, “Arrian”, Encyclopaedia Iranica (1986).Scholarly
  • Ernst Badian, “Diodorus Siculus”, Encyclopaedia Iranica (1995).Scholarly
  • Philip Huyse, “Curtius Rufus, Quintus”, Encyclopaedia Iranica (1993).Scholarly
  • Rüdiger Schmitt, “Cleitarchus”, Encyclopaedia Iranica (1992).Scholarly
  • George Karamanolis, “Plutarch”, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (2010, revised 2024).Scholarly
  • Christopher Shields, “Aristotle”, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (2008, revised 2020).Scholarly
  • Richard Stoneman, “Naming Alexander”, Lexicon of Greek Personal Names, University of Oxford.Scholarly
  • L. J. Schep, R. J. Slaughter, J. A. Vale and P. Wheatley, “Was the death of Alexander the Great due to poisoning? Was it Veratrum album?”, Clinical Toxicology 52(1) (2014), abstract.Scholarly
  • J. S. Marr and C. H. Calisher, “Alexander the Great and West Nile virus encephalitis”, Emerging Infectious Diseases 9(12) (2003).Scholarly
Put it to work
Our take

Keep the doubt the sources kept

The knot, the fire at Persepolis and his death were already argued over by the ancient writers. Popular stories keep the drama and drop that doubt. Our view: carry the doubt with you, and your retelling becomes more honest and harder to knock down.

Goes with: A short life ↑

Steps

Weigh sources the way the ancient writers did

  1. Prefer someone who was there. Arrian trusted Aristobulus because he had served on the expedition.
  2. Ask what they had to gain or lose. Arrian trusted Ptolemy partly because falsifying facts would have disgraced a king more. Our view: reputation can also tempt someone to polish a story.
  3. Count the versions. For the Gordian knot, Arrian gives two versions and says he cannot affirm with confidence how it was done.
  4. Trust lone colourful stories less. A story found only in the most colourful accounts deserves less confidence.
  5. Say when you're passing a story on. Arrian says he recorded the poison story so as not to seem ignorant, not because he believed it. Flag a story you doubt.

Goes with: What the sources can and can’t tell us ↑

This week

This week: tell one story both ways

Pick a story with two versions, from history or from your own work. Write each in one line, with its source. Then say which way the evidence leans, or that it's still open.

Goes with: 4. “He burned Persepolis in a drunken party” ↑

Steps

Write about a famous life fairly

  1. Keep the costs in. The same writers who admired him recorded Thebes and Tyre plainly. Include both sides of a record.
  2. Give figures as the sources give them. At Tyre the numbers differ between Arrian, Diodorus and Curtius. Name whose count you use.
  3. Leave the verdict to the reader. Set out what the record shows, and let readers judge the person.

Goes with: A short life ↑

Earn with it

Turn ancient sources into work

  • Give talks or podcast episodes that set the ancient versions side by side, with each writer named.
  • Tutor history or classics students in weighing sources: who was there, who wrote later, and who hesitated.
  • Offer research help to novelists, game designers or filmmakers who want to know which details have ancient support.

Ideas to explore, not financial or business advice. No result is promised.

Goes with: What the sources can and can’t tell us ↑