Start hereThe book says sleep was the second most important factor separating the best violinists from the good ones. Yet the study it draws on found that those two groups slept the same amount. So what else in Essentialism holds up?
About the book
Essentialism: The Disciplined Pursuit of Less is by Greg McKeown. Crown Business published it in April 2014; the publisher lists the hardcover at 272 pages, and the library catalogue record gives 260. The UK catalogue record describes McKeown as the CEO of a leadership and strategy agency in Silicon Valley.
It is a business and self-help book for a general reader. Its twenty short chapters sit in four parts. They are Essence (what the idea is), Explore (how to find what matters), Eliminate (how to cut the rest) and Execute (how to make the important work easier).
Less but better
The book’s motto comes from the designer Dieter Rams. The book describes Rams as the lead designer at Braun for many years, and sums up his approach in three German words: Weniger aber besser, “Less but better”.
McKeown sets “the disciplined pursuit of less” against what Jim Collins, in How the Mighty Fall, calls the undisciplined pursuit of more.
Does it hold up? Both borrowings check out. The tenth of Rams’s ten principles for good design reads “Less, but better”, as published by Vitsœ, the furniture company he has designed for since the 1950s. Vitsœ says he was appointed head of design at Braun in 1961 and held the post for 34 years.
In How the Mighty Fall, Jim Collins describes five stages through which great companies often decline; stage two is the undisciplined pursuit of more. The book adds that this is true for companies and for the people who work in them, which is McKeown’s argument rather than something Collins’s research tested.
One priority
McKeown argues that priority used to mean one thing. In his telling, the word came into English in the 1400s as a singular, meaning the very first or prior thing. “Only in the 1900s did we pluralize the term and start talking about priorities,” he writes.
Our reading: the point is that when everything is a priority, nothing is. As he puts it, “If you don’t prioritize your life, someone else will.”
Does it hold up? Half of it. The word is old: the Oxford English Dictionary’s earliest evidence is from before 1425, and Etymonline dates it to the late 1300s.
The plural is older than the book says. An 1843 law book by Joseph Story already writes of “the priorities among equitable incumbrancers”. In Google’s Ngram corpus of books, priorities is rare in the 1800s and becomes far more common from the 1940s on.
The vital few and the trivial many
Most things, he argues, matter much less than a few. He borrows the idea of the vital few from the quality-control engineer Joseph Juran, and builds the book around separating the vital few from the trivial many.
Does it hold up? As a rule of thumb, not a law. The book credits Joseph Juran’s 1951 Quality-Control Handbook with expanding the idea into the Law of the Vital Few.
Juran later wrote that he had generalised the idea himself and given it Vilfredo Pareto’s name. In 1974 he wrote that “I had mistakenly applied the wrong name to the principle”: Pareto had studied the unequal spread of wealth. Our Older Than You Think, Part 2 treats the 80/20 rule the same way.
Try it: look back at last month and list the few tasks or clients that produced most of the results.
Every yes is a trade-off
In the book, every yes is also a no to something else. The chapter title puts it as a question: Which problem do I want?
McKeown argues that we can try to avoid trade-offs, but we cannot escape them. The book’s answer is to make them on purpose.
Try it: when you say yes to something new, say out loud what it will push aside.
Explore before committing
Part II is about making room to see what matters: time to think (it holds up Bill Gates’s Think Week as an example), play, sleep, and strict criteria for choosing.
The strictest is what he calls the 90 Percent Rule. In the same chapter he describes a “HELL YEAH! or no” technique, which he credits to the TED speaker Derek Sivers.
Does it hold up? The credit is right. Sivers wrote: “If you’re not saying ‘HELL YEAH!’ about something, say no.” His post is dated 26 August 2009. The book credits him, and sets out its own 90 Percent Rule in the same chapter. Neither is a research finding; they are rules of thumb.
Try it: use a strict filter as an experiment for decisions that keep piling up, and drop it if it does not help.
Eliminate, gracefully
Part III is about cutting: saying a graceful no, leaving commitments that no longer fit, editing, and setting limits.
The aim is to say no without drama. It is also to stop putting time into things only because time has already gone into them: the chapter on leaving commitments is subtitled win big by cutting your losses.
Make the important work easy
Part IV is about execution: building buffers, because people underestimate how long things take; removing obstacles; noticing small wins; and turning the essential work into a routine.
Does it hold up? Often, not always. The term planning fallacy comes from Kahneman and Tversky (1979). In the 1994 study the book describes, 37 students were asked when they would finish their theses. The 33 who finished within the study’s follow-up had predicted 33.9 days on average and took 55.5.
Their worst-case estimates were also short, but that gap was not statistically significant. The same paper found that people did not underestimate other people’s completion times, and that the bias disappeared when people were asked to connect their past experience to their prediction.
A 2012 review found underestimation more common in engineering and management studies, but not in studies from psychology. Our Thinking, Fast and Slow summary gives the same verdict.
Try it: before you commit to a date, look up how long a similar job took last time.
What holds up, and where the book overstates
What the sources show for each idea
The borrowed ideas mostly check out: less but better is Rams’s principle, the HELL YEAH rule is Sivers’s, and the vital-few idea does go back to Juran. The research claims are shakier. The planning fallacy is real but not universal, and the word history of priority is half right.
The sleep claim does not match the study it comes from. The book says sleep was the second most important factor separating the best violinists from the good ones.
The study behind the sleep chapter is the same 1993 study of young violinists at a Berlin music academy that underlies the 10,000-hour idea. It compared three groups: the best violinists, good violinists, and violinists training to be music teachers.
On sleep, the paper says the weekly amount “did not differ for the two best groups and averaged 60.0 hr”. That is 8.6 hours a day, against 7.8 hours for the music teachers. The best and good groups also napped more, 2.8 hours a week against 0.9.
So the study does link more sleep with the groups that practised more, which is the book’s wider point. What it does not show is sleep separating the best violinists from the good ones, or any ranking of factors. It is also a correlation in a small group of students: it cannot show that sleep made anyone play better.
Who it’s for, and who can skip it
It suits readers who feel stretched across too many commitments and want permission, and some language, to do less. It is short, clear and encouraging.
Readers looking for evidence will find more stories than studies, and some of the research it cites says less than the book claims. If you already plan with buffers and say no easily, much of it will be familiar.
Quick answers
What is Essentialism about?
Greg McKeown's book, published in April 2014, argues for "the disciplined pursuit of less": decide what matters most, cut most of the rest, and make the important work easier to do.
Where does "less but better" come from?
It is the tenth of Dieter Rams's ten principles for good design. Vitsœ says he was appointed head of design at Braun in 1961 and held the post for 34 years.
Is the planning fallacy real?
Often, not always. In a 1994 study, students predicted they would finish their theses in 33.9 days on average and took 55.5. A 2012 review found underestimation more common in engineering and management studies, but not in studies from psychology.
Did people only start saying "priorities" in the 1900s?
The plural is older. The sense of "the most important thing" is a 20th-century shift, but an 1843 law book by Joseph Story already writes of "the priorities among equitable incumbrancers".
Where does the "HELL YEAH! or no" rule come from?
From Derek Sivers, in a post dated 26 August 2009, and the book credits him. It is a rule of thumb, not a research finding.
Use this
Choose fewer commitments on purpose, and plan from what happened last time.
If I say yes to this, what am I saying no to?
Quick quiz
Nothing is scored or saved. Recalling it once now is what makes it last.
1. Whose principle is the book's motto, "less but better"?
Answer: Dieter Rams.Read it again ↑
2. What did the 1993 violin study find about sleep in the best and the good violinists?
Answer: The two groups did not differ.Read it again ↑
3. In the 1994 planning-fallacy study, what made the bias disappear?
Answer: Connecting past experience to the prediction.Read it again ↑
How we checked this · Last checked October 2026
- What we read: the library catalogue records (US and UK editions), the publisher's page, and short passages of the 2014 Crown Business edition through the Open Library search-inside tool.
- Chapter names for the book's lines come from the search-inside passages and the catalogue's table of contents.
- For the sources we read the full texts of the 1993 violin study, the 1994 planning-fallacy study, Juran's 1974 note and the Etymonline entry; the OED's public earliest-use summary; and abstracts for the rest.
- Only the seven claims in the verdict table were set against sources; the book's other stories and examples were not checked.
Sources
- G. McKeown, Essentialism: The Disciplined Pursuit of Less (Crown Business, 2014): catalogue records (US edition, UK edition) and short passages via the Open Library search-inside tool; publisher’s page.Primary
- “priority, n.”, Oxford English Dictionary (earliest-use summary).Scholarly
- “priority”, Online Etymology Dictionary.Scholarly
- J. Story, Commentaries on Equity Jurisprudence, 3rd ed., vol. 2 (Boston, 1843).Primary
- Google Books Ngram Viewer, “priorities”, 1700–2019.Scholarly
- K. A. Ericsson, R. T. Krampe and C. Tesch-Römer, “The role of deliberate practice in the acquisition of expert performance”, Psychological Review 100 (1993).Scholarly
- R. Buehler, D. Griffin and M. Ross, “Exploring the ‘planning fallacy’”, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 67 (1994).Scholarly
- T. Halkjelsvik and M. Jørgensen, “From origami to software development”, Psychological Bulletin 138 (2012).Scholarly
- Vitsœ, “Ten principles for good design” and “Dieter Rams”.Primary
- D. Sivers, “No ‘yes.’ Either ‘HELL YEAH!’ or ‘no.’” (26 August 2009).Primary
- J. M. Juran, “The Non-Pareto Principle; Mea Culpa” (1974), Juran Institute.Primary
- J. Collins, “Five Stages of Decline”, from How the Mighty Fall (author’s website).Primary