Start hereIn a 1998 study, children praised for being smart showed less persistence after a failure. A close replication in 2019 found an effect on one test, but none on the eight motivation and attribution measures. So which of the book's claims hold up?
About the book
The author, Carol S. Dweck, is a psychologist who has taught at Stanford University since 2004, after fifteen years at Columbia University (1989 to 2004). Mindset: The New Psychology of Success was first published in hardcover on 28 February 2006, and in paperback in 2007. An updated edition, with a 2006, 2016 copyright line, added a section on false growth mindset. Its publisher, Ballantine Books, calls it a “million-copy bestseller”.
It is popular psychology for a general reader. It sets out two beliefs about ability. Then it follows them through chapters on ability and accomplishment, sport, business leadership, relationships, and parents, teachers and coaches. It ends with a chapter on changing mindsets.
Two beliefs about ability
In a fixed mindset, intelligence and talent are set amounts: you have them or you don’t. In a growth mindset, in the book’s words, your basic qualities are “things you can cultivate through your efforts, your strategies, and help from others”. Both are beliefs about ability, not fixed traits.
Is a growth mindset just effort?
Not in Dweck’s own account. In 2015 she wrote that equating a growth mindset with effort is “perhaps the most common misconception”. Students also need to try new strategies and seek input from others when they are stuck. The book itself defines the growth mindset as cultivating your qualities through efforts, strategies and help from others.
Try it: when you are stuck, change the method or ask someone, rather than only pushing harder.
The belief shapes how you meet difficulty
“The view you adopt for yourself profoundly affects the way you lead your life,” the book says. If ability is fixed, a hard task or a failure is a verdict on you, so it is safer to avoid it. If ability can grow, the same setback is information about what to do next.
Does the core idea hold up in the lab?
The core idea has some support in the lab, but the tests are mixed. A 2020 study of 438 people found no support for most of the theory’s premises. Li and Bates (2019) found children’s mindsets unrelated to how they recovered from failure.
Does a growth mindset go with better grades?
A link exists on average, and it is weak. A 2007 study of 373 seventh graders found that believing intelligence is malleable predicted rising maths grades. But a 2018 meta-analysis of 273 effect sizes from 365,915 students found the relationship between mindset and achievement weak. Li and Bates (2019) found no association between children’s mindsets and their grades.
Praise the process, not the person
The book’s advice to parents and teachers on praise comes from Dweck’s research with children. It says that praising children’s intelligence “harms their motivation and it harms their performance”. The alternative is to praise the process: what the child did.
The 2016 edition adds a caution. People often take the advice to mean praising the process rather than the outcome. Dweck calls that a common misconception: in her research, process praise is tied to the outcome.
Does praising intelligence backfire?
It is still argued. In 1998 Mueller and Dweck reported six studies with fifth graders. After a failure, children praised for intelligence showed less persistence, less enjoyment and worse performance than children praised for effort.
In 2019 Li and Bates closely replicated the first study with Chinese children. The praise was associated with performance on one post-failure test, but not with any of the eight motivation and attribution measures. Two further studies found no effect.
Other tests are mixed. A 2019 study of 108 vocational students, using a similar design, found no difference between the two kinds of praise. A 2018 study of 103 fifth graders, by Xing and colleagues, found that children praised for ability self-handicapped more and improved less. The book states the finding firmly; the later record is mixed.
Try it: name what someone did, such as the approach or the fix, and tie it to the result, as the 2016 edition describes. The studies on this kind of praise are mixed, so it is a habit to try, not a proven fix.
Talent is not the whole story
The book argues that people seen as naturals often worked their way there. Michael Jordan is one example: the book says he was not a natural and was “the hardest-working athlete, perhaps in the history of sport”.
Was Michael Jordan cut from his school team?
The book says he was cut from the high school varsity team, and that matches the record. In 1978 the varsity coach at Laney High School had one opening for a sophomore and gave it to a taller player. Jordan spent that season on the junior varsity, where he starred, and played his last two years on the varsity.
Mindsets can change
The last chapter is a workshop on changing mindsets. The idea also became the basis of short school lessons teaching students that intellectual abilities can be developed. Those lessons are what much of the later research tested, and whether they raise grades is still argued. That question has its own section below.
Nobody is purely one type
The 2016 edition says we are “a mixture of fixed and growth mindsets”. It also takes up what a colleague of Dweck’s called “false growth mindset”. In her 2015 essay Dweck describes it as educators who claimed a growth mindset but whose words and actions did not reflect it.
Are people one type or the other?
Here too the correction is Dweck’s own. In 2015 she wrote that researchers may have “talked too much about people having one mindset or the other, rather than portraying people as mixtures”.
Try it: notice the situations that bring out a fixed reaction in you, rather than labelling yourself as one type.
What holds up, and what the book overstates
What the sources show for each idea
The attitude at the centre of the book has some support, but the larger claims have had a harder time. The link between mindset and grades is weak on average. The famous praise study has one close replication that mostly did not repeat it. And whether short lessons help is a live dispute, set out below. We cover some of the same research in Mindsets, checked.
Do short school lessons raise grades?
This is a genuine disagreement, argued out in the same journal in 2023, so here are both sides.
The case for a small, targeted effect.
- Yeager and colleagues (Nature, 2019; Dweck is a co-author) ran a pre-registered study with a nationally representative sample of US secondary school students. A short online lesson, under an hour, improved grades among lower-achieving students and increased enrolment in advanced maths. It changed grades when peer norms aligned with the messages of the lesson.
- Burnette and colleagues (2023) found a small effect on academic achievement for targeted groups when the lessons were delivered as designed (d = 0.14). The spread was wide: their prediction interval ran from slightly negative to modest.
- Yeager and Dweck (2020) wrote that large studies justify confidence in the research, but that effects vary meaningfully across people and settings.
The case for little or no average effect.
- Macnamara and Burgoyne (2023) reviewed 63 studies and found a small overall effect that was “nonsignificant after correcting for potential publication bias”. Among the six highest-quality studies it was also nonsignificant.
- A trial funded by the Education Endowment Foundation tested a teacher-delivered programme in a large number of schools. Pupils did not make any additional progress in literacy or numeracy. The trial page gives one possible reason: many staff already knew similar growth mindset messages.
- The newest review we found, Gazmuri (2025), covered 24 randomised trials and found that the strongest studies showed “null or very small effect sizes”.
The exchange. Tipton and colleagues (2023, including Yeager) reanalysed Macnamara and Burgoyne’s data with Burnette’s methods and reported a meaningful, significant effect of growth mindset in at-risk groups. Macnamara and Burgoyne replied that Tipton and colleagues had changed effect sizes, how moderators were coded and which studies were included.
Where it leans. Our reading: the highest-quality studies, the large school trial and the 2025 review found little or no average effect, and the positive findings are for particular students in particular settings. So the evidence leans towards a small effect at most, for some students in some schools. That is much narrower than the publisher’s description, which says success can be “dramatically influenced” by how we think about ability.
Who it’s for, and who can skip it
It suits parents, teachers, coaches and managers who want a humane way to talk about ability and setbacks. It also suits anyone who tends to read every failure as a verdict on themselves.
Our reading: the core attitude is useful. The claims about how much it changes results are stronger in the book than in the research that followed, including research by Dweck’s own collaborators. If you already treat mistakes as information and give specific feedback, you can skip it. Readers who want the evidence can go straight to the 2023 Psychological Bulletin exchange.
Quick answers
Is growth mindset real?
The core idea has some support in the lab, but the tests are mixed. A 2020 study of 438 people found no support for most of the theory's premises.
Do growth mindset interventions work?
Researchers disagree. Our reading: the evidence leans towards a small effect at most, for some students in some schools.
Does praising a child's intelligence backfire?
A 1998 paper reporting six studies found it did, after a failure. A close replication in 2019 mostly did not repeat it, and other tests are mixed.
What is false growth mindset?
In Dweck's 2015 account, educators who claimed a growth mindset but whose words and actions did not reflect it.
Was Michael Jordan cut from his high school team?
In 1978 the varsity coach at Laney High School had one opening for a sophomore and gave it to a taller player. Jordan spent that season on the junior varsity.
Use this
Keep the attitude, and keep your expectations of it modest.
Is this a verdict on me, or information about what to try next?
Quick quiz
Nothing is scored or saved. Recalling it once now is what makes it last.
1. What did Dweck call "perhaps the most common misconception" about a growth mindset?
Answer: Equating it with effort.Read it again ↑
2. What did the 2019 close replication of the praise study find?
Answer: An effect on one test, none on the eight motivation and attribution measures.Read it again ↑
3. Where did Michael Jordan play in his sophomore season?
Answer: On the junior varsity.Read it again ↑
How we checked this · Last checked October 2026
- The book's wording comes from the publisher's page and short passages of the 2016 edition, found through the Internet Archive's search-inside tool.
- Dweck's own corrections come from her 2015 Education Week essay.
- For the studies we read the abstracts, including the four papers in the 2023 Psychological Bulletin exchange, and the Education Endowment Foundation's trial page.
- In October 2026 we searched again for newer reviews of growth-mindset lessons and found none later than Gazmuri (2025).
Sources
- C. S. Dweck, Mindset: The New Psychology of Success (Random House, 2006; updated edition, Ballantine, copyright 2006, 2016): publisher’s page; short passages of the 2016 edition through the Internet Archive’s search-inside tool.Primary
- Stanford Profiles, “Carol Dweck”.Primary
- C. S. Dweck, “Carol Dweck Revisits the ‘Growth Mindset’”, Education Week (22 September 2015).Primary
- C. M. Mueller and C. S. Dweck, “Praise for intelligence can undermine children’s motivation and performance”, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 75 (1998).Scholarly
- Y. Li and T. C. Bates, “You can’t change your basic ability, but you work at things”, Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 148 (2019).Scholarly
- J. Glerum, S. M. M. Loyens, L. Wijnia and R. M. J. P. Rikers, “The effects of praise for effort versus praise for intelligence on vocational education students”, Educational Psychology 40 (2019).Scholarly
- S. Xing et al., “Effects of ability and effort praise on children’s failure attribution, self-handicapping, and performance”, Frontiers in Psychology 9 (2018).Scholarly
- L. S. Blackwell, K. H. Trzesniewski and C. S. Dweck, “Implicit theories of intelligence predict achievement across an adolescent transition”, Child Development 78 (2007).Scholarly
- V. F. Sisk et al., “To what extent and under which circumstances are growth mind-sets important to academic achievement?”, Psychological Science 29 (2018).Scholarly
- A. P. Burgoyne, D. Z. Hambrick and B. N. Macnamara, “How firm are the foundations of mind-set theory?”, Psychological Science 31 (2020).Scholarly
- D. S. Yeager et al., “A national experiment reveals where a growth mindset improves achievement”, Nature 573 (2019).Scholarly
- D. S. Yeager and C. S. Dweck, “What can be learned from growth mindset controversies?”, American Psychologist 75 (2020).Scholarly
- B. N. Macnamara and A. P. Burgoyne, “Do growth mindset interventions impact students’ academic achievement?”, Psychological Bulletin 149 (2023).Scholarly
- J. L. Burnette et al., “A systematic review and meta-analysis of growth mindset interventions”, Psychological Bulletin 149 (2023).Scholarly
- E. Tipton et al., “Why meta-analyses of growth mindset and other interventions should follow best practices for examining heterogeneity”, Psychological Bulletin 149 (2023).Scholarly
- B. N. Macnamara and A. P. Burgoyne, “A spotlight on bias in the growth mindset intervention literature”, Psychological Bulletin 149 (2023).Scholarly
- Education Endowment Foundation, “Changing Mindsets”, effectiveness trial (completed July 2019).Scholarly
- C. Gazmuri, “Can growth mindset interventions improve academic achievement?”, Review of Education 13 (2025).Scholarly
- K. Sherrington, The Dallas Morning News, “The unkindest cut of all”, in The Seattle Times (11 January 1998).Popular