Start hereAbout one in five babies in Kagan's studies reacted strongly to new things. Yet that temperament raised, but did not fix, the chance of growing into a cautious child. So how much of being quiet is given?
About the book
Quiet: The Power of Introverts in a World That Can’t Stop Talking is by Susan Cain. Crown published it on 24 January 2012. It is popular psychology, mixing research on personality with history and the stories of people Cain interviewed.
It is addressed both to introverts and to the people who raise, manage or live with them. In February 2012 Cain gave a TED talk, “The power of introverts”, that covers its main arguments.
The Extrovert Ideal
Cain argues that American culture runs on what she calls the Extrovert Ideal: “the omnipresent belief that the ideal self is gregarious, alpha, and comfortable in the spotlight.” Introversion, along with sensitivity, seriousness and shyness, has become in her view a second-class trait.
Yet, she argues, many people are quiet, and some of the greatest ideas, art and inventions came from quiet people attuned to their inner worlds.
From character to personality
Part of the book is history. Cain draws on the historian Warren Susman, who described a shift in American culture from what he called “a Culture of Character to a Culture of Personality”.
Her example of the change is Dale Carnegie, whose public-speaking class at a YMCA in New York made his name as a promoter of the outgoing personality.
The New Groupthink
Cain calls the belief that creativity and productivity come from constant teamwork the New Groupthink, and argues that it shapes classrooms and open-plan offices. Her case rests partly on group brainstorming, which, she writes, “doesn’t actually work” (p. 88), and on the role of solitude in creative work.
She is clear in the TED talk that she is not against collaboration; her point is that solitude matters too.
Does it hold up? For brainstorming out loud, yes. A 1993 paper summed up the earlier research: it had consistently found that people working separately, whose ideas are pooled afterwards, out-produce groups that brainstorm out loud.
A 1987 set of experiments traced most of the loss to production blocking: in a talking group only one person can speak at a time. The exception is brainstorming by computer, where people type at once. In the 1993 study, 12-person electronic groups produced more ideas than 12 people working separately, and 6-person groups did as well.
On open-plan offices, the evidence is narrower. Open offices are meant to bring people together. A 2018 study followed two company headquarters as they moved into more open space. Face-to-face interaction fell by about 70% in both, while email and instant messaging rose.
It measured how people interacted, not output. On output it reports only that one company’s executives said productivity had fallen by their internal measures.
Try it: have everyone write ideas down alone first, then discuss them together.
Temperament is partly given
Several chapters cover the biology of temperament. Her centrepiece is the psychologist Jerome Kagan’s long-running study of babies. Some four-month-olds reacted strongly to new experiences, and Kagan predicted they would grow up to be introverts.
The infants who reacted most, “the 20 percent who’d hollered” and pumped their arms and legs, Kagan called high-reactive (p. 100). She also cites figures putting introversion-extroversion at “40 to 50 percent heritable” (p. 105). As the publisher’s teacher’s guide, by David and Michael Treadway, sums up the argument, “we can change who we are, but only to a certain degree.”
Does it hold up? The one-in-five figure does; the rest comes with limits. Kagan and Nancy Snidman’s own summary is that about 20 percent of healthy children are born with this temperamental bias.
But they wrote that the bias limits the chance of a consistently fearless, spontaneous profile. It does not determine an anxious or introverted one.
A 2003 brain-imaging study looked at adults who had been classed as inhibited or uninhibited in their second year of life. The inhibited group showed a stronger amygdala response to unfamiliar faces. The study described the two temperaments as moderately stable from infancy into early adolescence.
On heritability, a 2015 meta-analysis of behaviour-genetic studies, covering more than 100,000 people, put the average heritability of personality traits at 40%. Twin studies gave higher estimates (47%) than family and adoption studies (22%).
The book’s range matches the twin studies; the lower family and adoption figures are part of the picture too.
Try it: treat a cautious baby or child as someone with a tendency, not a fixed future.
Acting out of character, and recovering
The book draws on the psychologist Brian Little’s Free Trait Theory. People have fixed traits, but can act against them for the sake of “core personal projects”, things they care about deeply. Little’s term for the place you go to recover afterwards is a “restorative niche”.
Does it hold up? Partly: the first half does; whether it costs introverts anything depends on the study. In short laboratory studies, acting extraverted lifted people’s mood whatever their disposition, and introverts showed no cost.
In a one-week randomised trial in daily life, acting extraverted lifted mood and feelings of authenticity overall. But more introverted participants gained less, and reported more negative feelings, more tiredness and less authenticity. A 2026 correction to that trial reports that its moment-by-moment authenticity measure used two of the three items described.
But two other week-long studies, one in 2020 and a set of three in 2021, found the benefits about the same whatever a person’s level of extraversion. This is a genuine disagreement between studies, and it does not come down to how long they ran.
The authors of one suggest the difference lies in how the studies were run, with different measures and comparison conditions, or in simple sampling variability. Our reading: none of these studies settles how long or how often someone can act out of character before it wears them down. That is the question the book’s advice turns on.
Try it: after a demanding social event, plan time in a restorative niche of your own.
Quiet leadership
Cain argues that introverts are “routinely passed over for leadership positions”, although they tend to be careful and less likely to take outsize risks. Her main research example is a study by Adam Grant and colleagues, published in 2011. In her account, introverted leaders did better with teams of proactive employees, because they were more likely to listen and let good ideas run.
Does it hold up? It depends on the team. In that research, at 57 stores of a pizza delivery chain, stores with introverted managers earned higher profits when employees were proactive. Stores with extroverted managers did better when employees were passive.
A laboratory study with 163 students folding T-shirts, with leaders asked to act extraverted or introverted, found the same pattern.
Across 73 samples, though, a 2002 meta-analysis found extraversion to be “the most consistent correlate of leadership”, for both becoming a leader and being rated effective.
Try it: before asking which kind of leader to be, ask whether the team is proactive or passive.
A spectrum, not two boxes
Cain notes that Carl Jung, who popularised the terms, held that there is no such thing as a pure introvert or a pure extrovert. In the TED talk she adds that some people fall in the middle of the introvert-extrovert spectrum, and calls them ambiverts.
The book’s introduction also says that one third to one half of Americans are introverts. The book’s note points to work on the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator.
Does it hold up? About half, in one large test sample, but the line is a choice. In that test’s US national representative sample, reported in its 1998 manual, 50.7% chose introversion and 49.3% extraversion.
But introversion-extroversion is a continuous trait, not two types. A 1989 study found no support for the view that the test measures truly either-or preferences or distinct types. So the share called introverts depends on where the cut-off is drawn.
On ambiverts, a 2013 study of 340 call-centre sales representatives found revenue highest for people in the middle of the extraversion scale and lower at both ends. Earlier research, the paper notes, had found only weak and conflicting links between extraversion and sales.
We found no direct replication in PubMed or Crossref searches covering 2013 to 2026. A 2025 study of 1,190 employees that looked for curved links between personality and job performance reports a clear curve, in its abstract, only for conscientiousness.
Try it: read an introvert or extrovert test result as a point on a scale, not a category.
What holds up, and what the book overstates
What the sources show for each idea
The research behind the book’s main claims mostly holds up, with conditions worth knowing. Group brainstorming out loud does produce fewer ideas than people working alone, and Kagan’s high-reactive babies were real.
The figures for how many people are introverts, and how heritable the trait is, depend on how you count. The workplace findings, on leaders, open-plan offices and acting out of character, come from a small number of studies, several of them published after the book.
Who it’s for, and who can skip it
It suits introverts who have felt out of place in loud schools or offices, and managers, teachers and parents who want to understand them. It is warm and readable. Its research claims mostly hold up, though often with limits that later research has made clearer.
Readers who want the science of personality, not a case for quiet people, will find more in the research it draws on.
Quick answers
What is the main idea of Quiet?
Susan Cain argues that American culture prizes an Extrovert Ideal of the bold, sociable self, and that schools and workplaces built around it waste the strengths of quieter people.
What percentage of people are introverts?
The book says one third to one half of Americans. In one US national sample of the Myers-Briggs test, 50.7% chose introversion, but the trait is continuous, so the share depends on where the cut-off is drawn.
Is introversion genetic?
Partly. A 2015 meta-analysis put the average heritability of personality traits at 40%; twin studies gave higher estimates (47%) than family and adoption studies (22%).
What is an ambivert?
Someone in the middle of the introvert-extrovert spectrum. A 2013 study of call-centre sales representatives found revenue highest for people in the middle, but we found no direct replication.
Does group brainstorming work?
Brainstorming out loud produces fewer ideas than the same people working alone and pooling their ideas, mainly because only one person can speak at a time. Brainstorming by computer is the exception.
Use this
Make room for quiet work and quiet people, and match the setting to the person.
Does this setting let the quiet people here do their best work?
Quick quiz
Nothing is scored or saved. Recalling it once now is what makes it last.
1. Why do talking brainstorming groups produce fewer ideas, according to a 1987 set of experiments?
Answer: Only one person can speak at a time.Read it again ↑
2. In the pizza-store study, when did stores with introverted managers earn higher profits?
Answer: When employees were proactive.Read it again ↑
3. What did a 1989 study find about the Myers-Briggs test?
Answer: No support for truly either-or preferences or distinct types.Read it again ↑
How we checked this · Last checked October 2026
- What we read of the book: the publisher's description and introduction excerpt, the teacher's guide on the publisher's site by David and Michael Treadway, short search-inside passages from the scanned 2012 Crown edition (which give page numbers), and the transcript of Cain's 2012 TED talk.
- For the research: the Myers-Briggs technical brief, Knowledge at Wharton's report of the leadership study, the full texts of the 2018 open-office study and the 2020 week-long study, and the abstracts of the other studies.
- We did not read Rowan Bayne's book on the Myers-Briggs test, which Cain cites for the one-third-to-one-half figure, or the full text of the 2011 leadership paper.
- Whether acting out of character costs introverts anything is a genuine disagreement between studies; the page gives both sides and labels our reading.
Sources
- S. Cain, Quiet: The Power of Introverts in a World That Can’t Stop Talking (Crown, 2012): the publisher’s product page, introduction excerpt and teacher’s guide (the guide is by D. C. Treadway and M. T. Treadway); search-inside passages from the scanned 2012 Crown edition via Open Library; S. Cain, “The power of introverts”, TED2012 (February 2012).Primary
- The Myers-Briggs Company, “Technical brief for the MBTI Form M and Form Q assessments: Latin and North American Spanish”, Table 5 (US National Representative Sample); R. R. McCrae and P. T. Costa, “Reinterpreting the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator from the perspective of the five-factor model of personality”, Journal of Personality 57 (1989).Scholarly
- T. Vukasović and D. Bratko, “Heritability of personality: a meta-analysis of behavior genetic studies”, Psychological Bulletin 141 (2015); T. J. Bouchard and M. McGue, “Genetic and environmental influences on human psychological differences”, Journal of Neurobiology 54 (2003).Scholarly
- J. Kagan and N. Snidman, “Early childhood predictors of adult anxiety disorders”, Biological Psychiatry 46 (1999); C. E. Schwartz, C. I. Wright, L. M. Shin, J. Kagan and S. L. Rauch, “Inhibited and uninhibited infants ‘grown up’”, Science 300 (2003).Scholarly
- M. Diehl and W. Stroebe, “Productivity loss in brainstorming groups: toward the solution of a riddle”, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 53 (1987); A. R. Dennis and J. S. Valacich, “Computer brainstorms: more heads are better than one”, Journal of Applied Psychology 78 (1993).Scholarly
- A. M. Grant, F. Gino and D. A. Hofmann, “Reversing the extraverted leadership advantage”, Academy of Management Journal 54 (2011), as reported in “Analyzing effective leaders”, Knowledge at Wharton (2010); T. A. Judge, J. E. Bono, R. Ilies and M. W. Gerhardt, “Personality and leadership”, Journal of Applied Psychology 87 (2002).Scholarly
- E. S. Bernstein and S. Turban, “The impact of the ‘open’ workspace on human collaboration”, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B 373 (2018).Scholarly
- J. M. Zelenski, M. S. Santoro and D. C. Whelan, “Would introverts be better off if they acted more like extraverts?”, Emotion 12 (2012); R. Jacques-Hamilton, J. Sun and L. D. Smillie, “Costs and benefits of acting extraverted: a randomized controlled trial”, Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 148 (2019), and its correction (2026); S. Margolis and S. Lyubomirsky, “Experimental manipulation of extraverted and introverted behavior and its effects on well-being”, Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 149 (2020); Z. M. van Allen, D. L. Walker, T. Streiner and J. M. Zelenski, “Enacted extraversion as a well-being enhancing strategy in everyday life”, Collabra: Psychology 7 (2021).Scholarly
- A. M. Grant, “Rethinking the extraverted sales ideal: the ambivert advantage”, Psychological Science 24 (2013).Scholarly
- Q. C. Song, I.-S. Oh, Y. Kim and C. So, “Revisiting the nature and strength of the personality-job performance relations”, Journal of Applied Psychology 110 (2025).Scholarly