Start hereTwo meta-analyses found a small advantage for reading on paper. Yet a review of smartphone research says parts of the field are not yet mature enough for firm conclusions. So how much of The Shallows holds up?
About the book
W. W. Norton first published the book in 2010. Its subtitle, What the Internet Is Doing to Our Brains, repeats the subtitle of an earlier essay by Carr. That essay was “Is Google Making Us Stupid?”, which ran in The Atlantic in the July/August 2008 issue.
Its publisher lists it as a finalist for the Pulitzer Prize. A 10th-anniversary edition in 2020 added a new afterword that brings the story up to date, on smartphones and social media.
It is a work of argument for general readers. It mixes personal experience, the history of reading and writing, and neuroscience.
| 2008 | Carr's essay “Is Google Making Us Stupid?” runs in The Atlantic, July/August issue |
| 2010 | W. W. Norton publishes the book, subtitled “What the Internet Is Doing to Our Brains” |
| 2020 | A 10th-anniversary edition adds an afterword on smartphones and social media |
The medium shapes the mind
In the prologue, Carr starts from Marshall McLuhan’s point that every new medium changes us, whatever content it carries. The web, he argues, is no exception.
Its form, a stream of links, alerts and short pieces, matters more than any one thing we read on it. That is the thread through every idea below.
It started with his own reading
In chapter 1, he describes finding long reading harder than it used to be. He feels, as he puts it, that he is “always dragging my wayward brain back” to what he was reading. He reports others saying the same.
Brains are plastic
The book’s science chapters argue that the brain keeps changing with use. In chapter 2, Carr quotes the neuroscientist Michael Merzenich calling the adult brain “massively plastic”, and adds that its plasticity lessens as we get older.
If the brain adapts to what we practise, he argues, then hours of skimming and clicking train it to skim and click.
Does it hold up? The first part does. A 2000 study found that London taxi drivers, who spend years learning the city’s streets, had larger rear hippocampi than people who did not drive taxis. The size went with time spent on the job.
The step to the web is less firm. In chapter 7, the book quotes Gary Small: “Five hours on the Internet, and the naive subjects had already rewired” their brains.
The brain-scan research behind the book’s five-hour passage was small. The published 2009 study scanned 24 older adults once and called itself exploratory. Small’s group reads the extra activity in experienced searchers as a sign that searching is mentally stimulating.
The training follow-up was presented at a 2010 scientific meeting. Changed brain activity in a small study is not the same as worse thinking.
Tools of the mind
Maps, clocks and writing are what Carr, borrowing a term used by the sociologist Daniel Bell and others, calls “intellectual technologies”. Each changed how people think.
He recalls Socrates’ worry that writing would weaken memory. He also quotes Nietzsche, in the English translation Carr uses, saying that our writing equipment takes part in the forming of our thoughts.
Does it hold up? The Socrates part is in the text. In Plato’s Phaedrus, Socrates tells the story of King Thamus. Thamus warns the inventor of writing that it “will create forgetfulness in the learners’ souls, because they will not use their memories” (Jowett’s translation). Plato himself wrote the warning down.
The book made deep reading possible
In chapter 4, Carr argues that the printed book trained a rare kind of attention: long, quiet and focused on one thing. “In the quiet spaces opened up by the prolonged, undistracted reading of a book,” he writes, “people made their own associations”.
Does it hold up? Partly: for some kinds of reading, the screen costs a little. A 2018 meta-analysis of 54 studies from 2000 to 2017 found a small advantage for paper. It was larger when reading was timed, appeared with informational texts but not with stories, and grew over the years.
A 2019 meta-analysis of 33 experiments found much the same. Reading from screens did slightly worse for expository texts, with no difference for narrative ones and no reliable difference in reading time. Readers on paper were also better at judging how well they had understood.
Try it: read the next report you need to understand on paper, then summarise it without looking back.
| Informational texts | A small advantage for paper, larger when reading was timed |
| Stories | No difference between paper and screen |
| Reading time | No reliable difference |
| Judging your own understanding | Readers on paper were better at it |
What two meta-analyses, of 54 studies and of 33 experiments, found.
The Net is an interruption system
Here is the core of the book: “the Net seizes our attention only to scatter it.” He calls the web “an interruption system, a machine geared for dividing attention” (chapter 7).
He draws on research on hypertext and multitasking to argue that links and alerts add mental work and leave less for understanding.
Does it hold up? Partly. People do skim web pages. A 2008 analysis by the usability researcher Jakob Nielsen looked at an average web page. It estimated that users have time to read at most 28% of the words, and 20% is more likely.
On links, the book draws on a 2005 review of hypertext reading, which we could not open. A 2019 eye-tracking study found that several coloured words in a sentence did no harm to reading behaviour. With real links in web-like passages, readers re-read sentences whose links were on uncommon words. It tracked eye movements, not understanding.
The book also cites a 2009 Stanford study which, in Carr’s words, found heavy multitaskers “much more easily distracted”. A 2021 meta-analysis of 118 tests found the link between heavy media multitasking and poorer attention small. The studies compare groups, though, and do not show cause. Our Deep Work summary covers those studies in detail.
Try it: before you share or act on an article, go back and read it through.
Search and memory
In the later chapters he argues that leaning on the web as an outside memory changes what we bother to remember ourselves. In his view, it also changes what we are able to think with.
What holds up, and the open question
What the sources show for each idea
The book’s building blocks hold up better than its headline. Whether the web is making us shallower thinkers is still unsettled.
- A 2019 review in World Psychiatry found that the internet can produce both short-term and lasting changes in attention, memory and social thinking. It called the effects on young people’s development a priority for future research.
- A 2017 review of smartphone research called the field still limited and said that in some areas it was “not yet mature enough to endorse any firm conclusions”.
Our reading: there is some evidence of modest effects on attention and reading habits. The larger claim, that the web is making us worse thinkers, is not settled.
Where the book overstates, it is in leaning on small or early studies, such as the brain scans in idea 3, for a claim about how everyone thinks.
Who it’s for, and who can skip it
It suits readers who have felt their attention change and want a thoughtful, well-written account of why that might be.
It is an argument, not a review of the evidence. It draws on research to make its case, and some of that research is small or early. Readers who mainly want the science of screen reading may get more from the two meta-analyses in idea 5.
Quick answers
What is The Shallows about?
Nicholas Carr's 2010 book argues that the internet is changing how we think, not just what we read. Its subtitle repeats the subtitle of his 2008 Atlantic essay "Is Google Making Us Stupid?"
Is reading on paper better than reading on a screen?
For some reading, a little. Two meta-analyses found a small advantage for paper, mainly for informational texts and under time pressure, with little or no difference for stories.
Does the internet make us shallower thinkers?
It's still argued. Reviews find some effects of internet use on attention and memory, but also say the evidence is limited and, in places, not yet mature enough for firm conclusions.
Did Google searching really rewire people's brains in five hours?
Brain activity changed in a small training study presented at a 2010 meeting, which is not the same as worse thinking. The published 2009 study scanned 24 older adults once and called itself exploratory.
How much of a web page do people read?
Not much, at least on the web of 2008. Jakob Nielsen estimated that users have time to read at most 28% of the words on an average page, and 20% is more likely.
Use this
Match the format to the reading: paper for what you must understand, care with what you skim.
Am I skimming this or studying it, and does the format match?
Quick quiz
Nothing is scored or saved. Recalling it once now is what makes it last.
1. What did the 2000 study of London taxi drivers find?
Answer: Larger rear hippocampi, going with time on the job.Read it again ↑
2. In two meta-analyses, where did reading on paper do better than on screens?
Answer: Informational texts.Read it again ↑
3. Where does the story of King Thamus warning that writing will create forgetfulness come from?
Answer: Plato's Phaedrus.Read it again ↑
How we checked this · Last checked October 2026
- What we read: the publisher's page, Open Library and Internet Archive records, short passages from the 2011 Norton paperback and the Atlantic Books edition through Open Library's search-inside (a line or two at a time), the opening of Carr's 2008 essay, and Plato's Phaedrus in Jowett's translation.
- Chapter numbers for the book's lines come from those search-inside passages.
- For the studies we read the abstracts, and the full text of the 2020 review by Small's group.
- We could not open the 2005 hypertext review the book draws on; we report only that the book cites it.
- Idea 7, on search and memory, was not set against research for this page.
Sources
- Nicholas Carr, The Shallows: What the Internet Is Doing to Our Brains (W. W. Norton, 2010; paperback 2011; 10th-anniversary edition 2020): publisher’s page; Open Library record of the 2010 edition.Primary
- Nicholas Carr, “Is Google Making Us Stupid?”, The Atlantic (July/August 2008).Primary
- Plato, Phaedrus, tr. Benjamin Jowett, Project Gutenberg.Primary
- E. A. Maguire et al., “Navigation-related structural change in the hippocampi of taxi drivers”, PNAS (2000).Scholarly
- G. W. Small, T. D. Moody, P. Siddarth and S. Y. Bookheimer, “Your brain on Google”, American Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry (2009).Scholarly
- G. W. Small et al., “Brain health consequences of digital technology use”, Dialogues in Clinical Neuroscience (2020).Scholarly
- J. Nielsen, “How Little Do Users Read?”, Nielsen Norman Group (2008).Popular
- D. DeStefano and J.-A. LeFevre, “Cognitive load in hypertext reading: A review”, Computers in Human Behavior (2007; online 2005), as quoted in the book.Scholarly
- G. Fitzsimmons, M. J. Weal and D. Drieghe, “The impact of hyperlinks on reading text”, PLoS ONE (2019).Scholarly
- E. Ophir, C. Nass and A. D. Wagner, “Cognitive control in media multitaskers”, PNAS 106(37) (2009), 15583–15587, as cited in the book.Scholarly
- D. A. Parry and D. B. le Roux, “‘Cognitive control in media multitaskers’ ten years on: A meta-analysis”, Cyberpsychology 15(2) (2021).Scholarly
- P. Delgado, C. Vargas, R. Ackerman and L. Salmerón, “Don’t throw away your printed books”, Educational Research Review (2018).Scholarly
- V. Clinton, “Reading from paper compared to screens”, Journal of Research in Reading (2019).Scholarly
- J. Firth et al., “The “online brain”: how the Internet may be changing our cognition”, World Psychiatry (2019).Scholarly
- H. H. Wilmer, L. E. Sherman and J. M. Chein, “Smartphones and Cognition”, Frontiers in Psychology (2017).Scholarly
Act on the narrow finding
Carr's big claim, that the web makes us shallower thinkers, is still argued. A narrower one has tests behind it: in two meta-analyses, paper did a little better for informational texts, not stories. Our view: match the format to the reading. That costs little while the larger question stays open.
Set up a reading session that holds
- Decide: skim or study. Before you start, choose whether this is a skim or something you need to understand. Plan your time to match.
- Silence the alerts. Carr calls the web an interruption system. Our view: turn notifications off for the length of the session.
- Park the links. Note links to follow afterwards. A later eye-tracking study found less disruption than the book suggests. Our view: parking them still keeps your place.
- One text, one window. Close the other tabs while you read something long.
- Write down what you want to keep. Carr argues that leaning on search changes what we remember. If that concerns you, note the ideas you want to keep.
This week: paper versus screen, your own test
Read two pieces you need to understand: one on paper, one on screen with alerts off. Pick two of similar length and difficulty. After each, write a short summary without looking back. Compare them. Our view: one person's test proves little, but it can hint at what suits you.
Turn reading know-how into work
- Edit web pages for readers who skim: the main point first, and headings that carry the message.
- Make print-friendly versions of long guides or reports, for readers who need to study them closely.
- Tutor students in study reading: when to switch to paper, and how to check what they understood.
Ideas to explore, not financial or business advice. No result is promised.