Start hereAllen writes that there is no element of chance in a person's circumstances. Yet a study of more than 40 million American children found that a child's chances varied widely with parent income and place. So which of his ideas hold up?
About the book
As a Man Thinketh is James Allen’s short book on the power of thought. The introduction to a 2019 edition says it is credited as one of the first popular self-help books.
According to the introduction to a 2019 St. Martin’s edition, Allen was born in Leicester, England, in 1864. He worked long hours as a framework knitter, read the writers of the New Thought movement, and died in 1912. The same introduction says the book was first published in 1903 and was his third.
It is very short: about 7,500 words in seven sections, from Thought and Character to Serenity. The book is in the public domain. The Project Gutenberg text (eBook #4507) is an undated “Authorized Edition” published in New York whose foreword Allen signed from Ilfracombe, England.
Where the title comes from
The title quotes Proverbs 23:7: “For as he thinketh in his heart, so is he”. In the King James Bible the line sits in a warning about the bread “of him that hath an evil eye”, whom the New Revised Standard Version calls “the stingy”. The NRSV renders verse 7 quite differently, and notes that the meaning of the Hebrew is uncertain.
In both versions the warning is about the host: in the King James his heart is not with you, and in the NRSV the host does not mean it. The verse describes a host whose hidden thoughts differ from his welcome. It says nothing about thinking your way to a better life.
Thought makes character
Allen opens with the line he took for his title and pushes it as far as it will go. Every act, he says, grows from the hidden seeds of thought: “A man is literally what he thinks, his character being the complete sum of all his thoughts.”
The mind is a garden
His central picture is a garden that will grow something either way: if no useful seeds are put in, weeds grow. The work is to tend it, weeding out some thoughts and cultivating others.
Circumstances follow thought
Allen argues that outer conditions are in harmony with a person’s inner state. In his words, “a man cannot directly choose his circumstances, but he can choose his thoughts, and so indirectly, yet surely, shape his circumstances.”
He goes further: in the arrangement of a person’s life, he writes, there is “no element of chance”. He adds a caution of his own: no one else can judge a person’s inner state from the outside of their life alone.
Does it hold up? A large US study links family and place to very different chances.
A study of more than 40 million American children found that a 10 percentile increase in parent income is associated with a 3.4 percentile increase in a child’s income. The chance of rising from the bottom fifth of incomes to the top fifth was 4.4% in Charlotte but 12.9% in San Jose.
Try it: when a plan goes wrong, list what was in your control and what was not, before deciding what to change.
The body follows thought
The health chapter makes the book’s strongest claims: “Disease and health, like circumstances, are rooted in thought.” He even writes that a change of diet will not help someone who will not change their thoughts.
He writes that anxiety opens the body to disease, that someone with purified thoughts need not consider germs, and that no physician equals cheerful thought.
Does it hold up? Only in a much narrower form. In a 1991 study, 394 volunteers were given cold viruses on purpose. Rates of infection and of colds rose step by step with psychological stress, and the link held after allowing for age, smoking, sleep and other factors.
But infection ran from about 74% in the least stressed to about 90% in the most stressed: most people were infected at every level. Stress was measured, not assigned, so the study shows an association.
The closest test of cheerful thought as medicine is placebo research, and it finds small effects at most.
A Cochrane review of 234 trials comparing placebo with no treatment found no important clinical effects of placebo in general. In some settings placebos can influence what patients report, especially pain and nausea, and the authors add that such effects are hard to tell apart from biased reporting.
Outlook and health are linked too. A 2019 meta-analysis of 15 studies with 229,391 participants found optimism significantly associated with a lower risk of cardiovascular events and with lower death rates from all causes. The studies observed people rather than changing their outlook, the results varied a lot between studies, and the authors call for studies of interventions.
Try it: read the health chapter as a set of claims to weigh, not a law. In the research, stress and outlook are linked to health as risks and averages.
Purpose and effort
Without purpose, he says, thought drifts. He asks for a central purpose or, failing that, the faultless performance of everyday duties. He treats failure as part of the process: the strength of character gained counts even when a purpose is missed.
He stresses effort, though he also writes “To desire is to obtain”. A person gets, he says, not what they wish and pray for but what they justly earn, and the result is measured by the strength of the effort.
Vision, then work
Allen writes: “Dream lofty dreams, and as you dream, so shall you become.” He also separates the Vision from the idle wish. He describes people who look at someone’s success and call it luck, without seeing the trials, failures and struggles behind it.
Does it hold up? It depends on the kind of thinking. In four studies, Gabriele Oettingen and Doris Mayer found that positive expectations (judging a desired future as likely) predicted high effort and successful performance. The reverse was true for positive fantasies, enjoying thoughts and images of that future.
The studies followed people looking for jobs, students with a crush, students before an exam and patients having hip replacements, for weeks to two years. Allen’s own text contains both: the dreams, and the insistence on effort.
Try it: after picturing a goal, ask a second question: how likely is it, and what would you have to do? That is the line the expectation studies drew.
Serenity
The book ends on calm as a skill learned over time: “Calmness of mind is one of the beautiful jewels of wisdom. It is the result of long and patient effort in self-control.”
What holds up, and where it goes too far
What the sources show for each idea
The research findings are about odds and averages: stress was linked to higher infection rates, optimism to lower heart risk, and expectations to effort. Allen states laws: “Good thoughts and actions can never produce bad results,” and “Suffering is always the effect of wrong thought in some direction.”
No study we found supports those absolutes, and the study of family income above suggests that where people start counts for a good deal.
Repeating positive statements about yourself is a practice close to the book’s ideas, and its evidence is mixed. A 2009 study found it left people with low self-esteem feeling worse, and two 2020 replications found no difference between conditions.
Our article on affirmations covers that research. It also covers the law of attraction, an idea close to Allen’s line “The soul attracts that which it secretly harbours”, which has no scientific support.
Who it’s for, and who can skip it
It suits readers who want a short, devotional book about attention and character, and anyone curious about where modern self-help language comes from. It is written as moral teaching, not argument.
It places responsibility for poverty and illness on the person’s own thoughts. He writes that “A man does not come to the almshouse or the jail by the tyranny of fate or circumstance.” He also writes: “The people who live in fear of disease are the people who get it.” Readers who are ill, or caring for someone who is, may find those passages hard.
Readers can weigh them for themselves. The chapter on serenity is the gentlest place to start.
Quick answers
What is the main message of As a Man Thinketh?
That thought shapes character, circumstances and even health. Allen writes that a man is literally what he thinks, his character being the complete sum of all his thoughts.
Where does the title As a Man Thinketh come from?
From Proverbs 23:7. In the King James Bible the line sits in a warning about a stingy host who does not mean his welcome; a modern translation renders it quite differently and notes that the meaning of the Hebrew is uncertain.
When was As a Man Thinketh published?
The introduction to a 2019 edition says it was first published in 1903 and was Allen's third book. Allen was born in Leicester, England, in 1864, and died in 1912.
Is As a Man Thinketh scientific?
It is moral teaching, not argument. Research supports narrower versions of some claims, such as a link between stress and colds, but no study we found supports its absolutes about chance and illness.
Is As a Man Thinketh in the public domain?
Yes. Allen died in 1912 and the book is in the public domain; Project Gutenberg publishes the text as eBook #4507.
Use this
Keep Allen's habits of attention, and treat his absolutes as claims to test.
Is this a habit of mind I can practise, or a law the evidence doesn't support?
Quick quiz
Nothing is scored or saved. Recalling it once now is what makes it last.
1. Where does the book's title come from?
Answer: Proverbs 23:7.Read it again ↑
2. In Oettingen and Mayer's studies, what predicted less effort?
Answer: Positive fantasies.Read it again ↑
3. In the 1991 cold-virus study, about what share of the least-stressed volunteers were infected?
Answer: About three in four.Read it again ↑
How we checked this · Last checked October 2026
- Quotations from the book come from the Project Gutenberg text (eBook #4507), an undated Authorized Edition. Biographical details come from the introduction to a 2019 St. Martin's edition, excerpted on the publisher's page.
- Proverbs 23 was read in the King James Version (Project Gutenberg) and the New Revised Standard Version (oremus Bible Browser).
- For the research we read the abstracts of the studies listed, not the full papers.
- The book's length, about 7,500 words, is our own count of the Gutenberg text.
- Every quoted passage was checked again against its source on 13 October 2026.
Sources
- James Allen, As a Man Thinketh, Project Gutenberg eBook #4507.Primary
- Joel Fotinos, introduction to As a Man Thinketh: The Complete Original Edition (St. Martin’s Essentials, 2019), excerpt on the publisher’s page.Popular
- The King James Bible, Proverbs 23:6–8, Project Gutenberg eBook #10.Primary
- New Revised Standard Version, Proverbs 23:6–8, oremus Bible Browser.Primary
- Raj Chetty, Nathaniel Hendren, Patrick Kline and Emmanuel Saez, “Where is the Land of Opportunity?”, NBER Working Paper 19843 (2014).Scholarly
- Sheldon Cohen, David Tyrrell and Andrew Smith, “Psychological stress and susceptibility to the common cold”, New England Journal of Medicine 325, 606–612 (1991), abstract.Scholarly
- Asbjørn Hróbjartsson and Peter Gøtzsche, “Placebo interventions for all clinical conditions”, Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews (2010), abstract.Scholarly
- Alan Rozanski et al., “Association of Optimism With Cardiovascular Events and All-Cause Mortality”, JAMA Network Open 2(9) (2019), abstract.Scholarly
- Gabriele Oettingen and Doris Mayer, “The motivating function of thinking about the future”, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 83(5), 1198–1212 (2002), abstract.Scholarly
- Joanne V. Wood, W. Q. Elaine Perunovic and John W. Lee, “Positive self-statements: power for some, peril for others”, Psychological Science 20(7) (2009), abstract.Scholarly
- Maureen K. Flynn and Michael J. Bordieri, “On the failure to replicate past findings regarding positive affirmations and self-esteem”, Journal of Contextual Behavioral Science 16 (2020), abstract.Scholarly