Start hereRobert Kiyosaki's "poor dad" was Hawaii's state superintendent of schools in the late 1960s. Yet, by his son's account, he died broke. So what does "poor" mean in the title?
This is a review of what Rich Dad Poor Dad argues and what can be checked about it. It describes the book and recommends no investment; nothing on this page is financial advice. Hacks Vitae is not affiliated with or endorsed by The Rich Dad Company.
About the book
Rich Dad Poor Dad was first published in 1997. It is written by Robert Kiyosaki with Sharon L. Lechter, a CPA. Its full title sets out its promise: What the Rich Teach Their Kids About Money That the Poor and Middle Class Do Not.
The book is built as a story about two father figures. The Rich Dad company presents it as a challenge to conventional beliefs about money, and a case for financial education as a pathway to wealth. The company calls it an international bestseller.
Two dads, two attitudes
Poor dad is Kiyosaki’s own father, Ralph Kiyosaki. In 2000 the Honolulu Star-Bulletin described him as a teacher, state superintendent of schools in the late 1960s, and an unsuccessful Republican candidate for lieutenant governor.
The Rich Dad company describes him as “a highly educated man with a Ph.D. in Education”. We could not find an independent record of an earned doctorate.
The University of Hawaii’s Board of Regents lists, among the honorary degrees it has conferred, “Ralph Kosaki, superintendent of education, 1991”. The university’s archives also hold a file titled “Honorary Degrees - Ralph Kiyosaki”.
His son told the Star-Bulletin that for all his public service his father “died broke”. By the son’s account, he lost his job after the election, then put his retirement money into a franchise that failed.
So “poor” in the title does not mean a low earner. Ralph Kiyosaki held one of the senior public education posts in Hawaii. The book’s contrast is about attitudes to money, not about income.
Rich dad, in the Rich Dad company’s account, was the father of Kiyosaki’s best friend Mike, whom he met at the age of nine. The company calls him a successful entrepreneur and investor who taught the boys about money while playing Monopoly.
Kiyosaki has declined to name him. In the same 2000 interview Kiyosaki said: “I have an agreement with the family that I won’t disclose who he is… but it’s a true story.” He added that the man had asked to be described in the book as having died, though he was still alive.
The company describes poor dad as an employee all his life who wanted nothing more than security.
Does it hold up? The two dads are one family’s story, and its central figure cannot be checked. The book’s claims about how each man thought come from one family’s story, not from research. Our reading: it works best as a parable, two ways of thinking about money given two faces.
Try it: when you think about money this week, notice whether you are thinking about safety, or about what your money is doing.
School doesn’t teach money
Kiyosaki’s central complaint is that school does not teach people about money. The Rich Dad company’s own tagline is “What school doesn’t teach you about money.”
In the 2000 interview he went further: “what causes people to be rich or poor is their vocabulary, what they say”. He recalled his father saying he would never be rich, and said it became a self-fulfilling prophecy.
Does it hold up? The vocabulary claim is Kiyosaki’s, drawn from his own family. Research has tested a wider question: does teaching people about money change what they do? Two large reviews point in different directions.
-
A 2014 meta-analysis by Daniel Fernandes, John Lynch and Richard Netemeyer covered 201 prior studies. It found that interventions to improve financial literacy explained only 0.1% of the variance in the financial behaviours studied, with weaker effects in low-income samples.
The effect also decays: even large interventions with many hours of instruction had negligible effects on behaviour 20 months or more later. They suggested a narrower role for “just-in-time” financial education tied to the specific behaviours it is meant to help.
-
A 2022 meta-analysis by Tim Kaiser, Annamaria Lusardi, Lukas Menkhoff and Carly Urban covered 76 randomised experiments with over 160,000 people. It found that financial education programmes have, on average, “positive causal treatment effects on financial knowledge and downstream financial behaviors”. The effects were similar to those of educational interventions in other fields.
The later review is restricted to randomised experiments and accounts for publication bias, which is a reason to give it weight.
Its 2020 working-paper version reported effects at least three times as large as the average in earlier work. The earlier one is a reason not to expect a single course to change behaviour for years. Neither tests the book’s specific claims.
Try it: learn about a money topic close to the time you will use it, as the 2014 review suggests; the 2022 review does not test timing.
An asset puts money in your pocket
By that test, a car usually counts as a liability, and so does the home you live in. The Rich Dad site says Kiyosaki argued that a home is not necessarily an asset if it keeps taking money out of your pocket every month without putting any in.
Does it hold up? As a definition, it is not the accountant’s. Under the International Accounting Standards Board’s 2018 Conceptual Framework, an asset is “a present economic resource controlled by the entity as a result of past events”.
An economic resource, in turn, is “a right that has the potential to produce economic benefits”. On that kind of definition, a home you own counts as an asset whether or not it produces income.
The two definitions answer different questions. The accountant’s asks what you own. Kiyosaki’s asks what your possessions do to your cash each month. Our reading: both can be useful, as long as you know which one is in use.
Try it: for one thing you own, ask whether it adds to or takes from your cash each month.
| Kiyosaki | Puts money into your pocket |
| Accounting | A present economic resource controlled as a result of past events |
| Your home, Kiyosaki | A liability if it takes money out every month |
| Your home, accounting | An asset whether or not it earns income |
Rich Dad company pages; IASB Conceptual Framework (2018).
Income that arrives whether you work or not
In the Rich Dad account, an asset is something that puts money in your pocket whether you are working or not. The company’s own example is a rental property with positive cash flow.
Two things are worth keeping in view. Income that needs little work to keep can still take a lot of work, money and risk to set up. And any income from an investment can fall or stop. Our reading: the company’s own pages describe the destination more vividly than the risks on the way.
The Cashflow Quadrant, from the follow-up book
The Cashflow Quadrant comes from Kiyosaki’s follow-up book, Rich Dad’s CASHFLOW Quadrant. The Rich Dad store presents it as the place to go next after Rich Dad Poor Dad.
It sorts people by where their income comes from:
- E: employee
- S: small business owner or self-employed
- B: big business owner
- I: investor
Which quadrant you are in depends, the company says, on where your cash comes from. It places employees and the self-employed on the left side, and people whose cash comes from businesses or investments they own on the right.
It also claims that “the Es and Ss pay the most in taxes and trade their time for money”. Tax rules differ by country and change over time, so that claim depends on where you live.
What holds up, and what can’t be checked
-
The rich dad cannot be checked. His identity is private by Kiyosaki’s own account, as set out above.
-
Criticism. ABC News noted in 2012 that the book became a New York Times best-seller even though his personal finance tips, such as his emphasis on real estate investing, drew criticism.
-
Business setbacks. Rich Global LLC, one of Kiyosaki’s companies, filed for Chapter 7 bankruptcy in a Wyoming court in August 2012.
ABC News reported that the company had been weighed down by a lawsuit from the Learning Annex, which had helped arrange his speaking events. A district judge in New York awarded the Learning Annex $23.7 million. ABC described it as a corporate bankruptcy filed through one of his companies.
-
One family’s story is not evidence. The book’s claims about how rich and poor people think are drawn from two men, one of them anonymous.
-
Tax and property rules are local. Anything the book says about tax or property is a starting point for questions, not an answer where you live. Tax, law and investing questions are for a qualified professional.
Who it’s for, and who can skip it
Our reading: it suits readers who want a simple story that makes them look at where their money goes. Readers who want tested evidence, or rules for their own country’s tax and property law, will need other sources: its case rests on one family’s story, and those rules differ by country.
Quick answers
Did Robert Kiyosaki's father have a PhD?
The Rich Dad company says he had "a Ph.D. in Education". We could not find an independent record of an earned doctorate. The University of Hawaii's list of honorary degrees includes "Ralph Kosaki, superintendent of education, 1991", and its archives hold a file titled "Honorary Degrees - Ralph Kiyosaki".
Is your home an asset or a liability?
By Kiyosaki's cash-flow test, a home you live in is not necessarily an asset if it keeps taking money out every month. On an accounting-style definition like the IASB's, a home you own counts as an asset whether or not it earns income.
What about Napoleon Hill's Think and Grow Rich?
It is an older book, published in 1937, that makes auto-suggestion its third "step toward riches". Like the rich dad, its origin story is hard to check: Hill's account that Andrew Carnegie set him his task appeared only after Carnegie died in 1919. Our page on affirmations covers his method and the research on it.
Use this
Use the book's ideas as questions about your own money, not as instructions.
- Write down where your income comes from: a job, a business you run, or things you own.
- When someone calls something an asset, ask which definition they are using.
- Treat the two dads as a parable, and judge each idea on its own evidence.
What does this do to my cash each month, and which meaning of asset is in use?
Quick quiz
Nothing is scored or saved. Recalling it once now is what makes it last.
1. How many prior studies did the 2014 meta-analysis cover?
Answer: 201.Read it again ↑
2. Under the IASB's 2018 Conceptual Framework, what is an asset?
Answer: A present economic resource controlled by the entity as a result of past events.Read it again ↑
3. What example of an asset does the Rich Dad company give?
Answer: A rental property with positive cash flow.Read it again ↑
How we checked this · Last checked October 2026
- The two dads come from Kiyosaki's own interview with the Honolulu Star-Bulletin (10 July 2000) and the Rich Dad company's biography of him.
- The book's ideas are given in the words of the Rich Dad company's own pages on assets and liabilities, the home and the Cashflow Quadrant, and its store page.
- For the doctorate, we looked for a record of an earned degree and found none. The University of Hawaii records are a Board of Regents list and an archives file title; the file itself was not read.
- The research comes from the abstracts of the 2014 and 2022 meta-analyses and the 2020 working paper.
- The accounting definition is from the IFRS Foundation's 2018 project summary, page 8; the bankruptcy is from ABC News, 12 October 2012.
Sources
- Honolulu Star-Bulletin, “Features: Robert Kiyosaki”, 10 July 2000.Popular
- Rich Dad, “Robert Kiyosaki” (company biography).Primary
- University of Hawaii Board of Regents, Honorary Degrees.Primary
- University of Hawaii at Manoa Library, archives catalogue: “Honorary Degrees - Ralph Kiyosaki” (file title; University President’s records, 1984-1992).Scholarly
- Rich Dad, “Assets vs. Liabilities: The Difference is Life Changing” and “Your Home is Not an Asset… Could it Be?”.Primary
- Rich Dad, “Rich Dad Fundamentals: The CASHFLOW Quadrant”, and the Rich Dad Store page for Rich Dad’s CASHFLOW Quadrant.Primary
- IFRS Foundation, Conceptual Framework for Financial Reporting: Project Summary, March 2018, p. 8.Primary
- Fernandes, D., Lynch, J. G., & Netemeyer, R. G. (2014). Financial Literacy, Financial Education, and Downstream Financial Behaviors. Management Science, 60(8), 1861–1883. doi:10.1287/mnsc.2013.1849.Scholarly
- Kaiser, T., Lusardi, A., Menkhoff, L., & Urban, C. (2022). Financial education affects financial knowledge and downstream behaviors. Journal of Financial Economics, 145(2), 255–272. doi:10.1016/j.jfineco.2021.09.022. Published abstract (RePEc). The 2020 working paper: NBER w27057.Scholarly
- Napoleon Hill, Think and Grow Rich (1937), contents, at sacred-texts.com.Primary
- Matt Novak, “The Untold Story of Napoleon Hill, the Greatest Self-Help Scammer of All Time”, Gizmodo, 6 December 2016.Popular
- Susanna Kim, “‘Rich Dad, Poor Dad’ Author Files for Bankruptcy for His Company”, ABC News, 12 October 2012.Popular