Start hereThe 1908 study behind the famous stress curve was about mice and electric shocks. The words arousal, anxiety and performance don't appear in it. So how did it end up in a diagram about your comfort zone?
The verdicts
Try it: find your next stretch
Pick one skill and size the next step for it. You can do this on paper, in a notes app or in the stretch finder below.
- Name the skill you want to build.
- Pick the next step and rate how hard it feels, from 1 (no effort at all) to 10 (overwhelming).
- If it’s under about 4, make it harder. Add a little difficulty, an audience or a time limit, or use less help.
- If it’s over about 7, make it smaller. Shorten it, slow it down, or bring in help.
- Write down the step that feels like a 5 or 6.
- Add one if-then plan: “If [time or situation], then I will [step].”
The 1 to 10 scale and the 4 and 7 cut-offs are our own rule of thumb, not research. We found no study that sets these numbers.
The if-then plan has more behind it. If-then plans help people follow through, though the effect is small once publication bias is allowed for. Our goal funnel guide covers them in more depth.
A redrawn diagram: the zones belong to the task
Here is our own version of the comfort-zone picture, in words. It isn’t a research finding, but it uses the parts that hold up.
The zones belong to a task, not to you. You can be calm giving a toast to friends and frozen giving the same toast to a hall of strangers. So the useful question isn’t whether you are in your comfort zone. It’s where this next step sits.
For any one task, a step can sit in one of four places:
- Too easy: you can do it without much thought. Useful for keeping a skill, less so for building one.
- Stretch: you can do it with effort, some mistakes and perhaps some help. This is where Vygotsky’s help from someone more capable and Bjork’s desirable difficulties sit.
- Too big: you can’t yet respond to it, so most of your effort goes into coping. In Bjork’s terms, the difficulty has become undesirable.
- Panic: the step feels threatening, not just hard. The three-zone model keeps this zone; the four-zone diagram leaves it out.
Nerves aren’t the test. A stretch can feel uncomfortable, and an easy step can feel calm. The question is whether you can still respond to what the step asks of you.
The panic zone here is a word from teaching models, not a diagnosis. If fear or anxiety often gets in the way of everyday life, that is worth talking over with a doctor or a mental-health professional.
Our own version, not a research finding.
Worked examples
Here is how the zones might look for four common goals. They are examples of sizing a step, not recommendations.
| Skill | Too easy | Stretch | Too big |
|---|---|---|---|
| Public speaking | Reading your notes aloud on your own | A two-minute talk to a few friends | A long speech to a full hall next week |
| The gym | A routine you can do half-asleep | One new exercise, learned slowly with good form | A weight far heavier than you have ever tried |
| A new language | Reviewing words you already know | A five-minute chat with a patient partner | A fast film with no subtitles |
| A career change | Reading about the new field | A short course, or a talk with someone who does the work | Quitting your job tomorrow with no plan |
Notice that the stretch column often adds help or shrinks the step. The friends, the partner and the person who does the work all play the more capable helper in Vygotsky’s definition.
One stretch a week
A simple practice is to keep a one-line log. Once a week, write down:
- the skill;
- the step you tried;
- how hard it felt before you tried it, from 1 to 10;
- how hard it felt afterwards;
- the next step.
Over a few weeks, the log can show a step moving from stretch to easy, which is the comfort zone growing in the way the three-zone model describes.
Checking your progress has some research behind it. A 2016 meta-analysis of 138 studies found that monitoring progress helped people reach goals, more so when progress was recorded or shared. The weekly rhythm itself is a habit, not a finding.
When a step doesn’t fit
- If it feels too big on your own, try help before you shrink it. A teacher, a partner or a smaller version of the task can turn a step that is too big into a stretch.
- If it feels threatening, not just hard, make it smaller rather than pushing harder. In the three-zone model, the panic zone is where fear blocks learning, so a smaller step is the way back.
- If it feels uncomfortable, that alone tells you little. Discomfort often comes with learning, but it doesn’t prove you’re learning.
- If the goal itself feels too big, keep the goal and resize this week’s step. A big goal can stay big while today’s step gets smaller or harder.
Where the zone diagrams come from
The picture is familiar: a small circle labelled “comfort zone”, with bigger rings for fear, learning and growth. It joins several older ideas, and some parts hold up better than others.
An experiment with mice
The story usually starts with Robert Yerkes and John Dodson. In 1908 they published a study of how fast mice learned a simple choice. Each mouse had to choose between a white box and a black box. Going into the black box gave it an unpleasant electric shock. Forty mice took part.
The researchers changed two things: how strong the shock was, and how hard the two boxes were to tell apart.
- When the boxes were easy to tell apart, the mice learned faster as the shock got stronger, up to the strongest shock the researchers thought safe to use.
- When the boxes were hard to tell apart, both weak and strong shocks slowed learning. A shock nearer the weak end worked best.
The groups were small. In one set of experiments, only one pair of mice was trained at each shock strength. The authors also called one of their conclusions tentative, open to correction by later research.
The paper is about shocks, mice and how fast they learned. The words arousal, anxiety and performance don’t appear in it.
How the experiment became a stress curve
The famous upside-down U came later. A 2007 review traces it to the 1950s, when Donald Hebb and others argued that performance rises with arousal and then falls. They did so, the review says, without citing Yerkes and Dodson. In its words, Hebb’s single curve “incorrectly came to be known as the Yerkes-Dodson law”. From the 1960s on, the law shrank into one inverted-U curve in psychology textbooks.
A 1994 paper by the psychologist Karl Halvor Teigen traced the retelling. Later writers recast the law as the effect of motivation, arousal, anxiety or stress on learning and performance, changes that, he wrote, “are often misattributed to Yerkes and Dodson themselves.”
Whether a bit of stress helps is still argued:
- A 2007 review calls it “a well-cited, but misunderstood, century-old principle”. In its reading, the link between arousal and performance can be a straight line or a curve, depending on how hard the task is.
- A 2015 paper on work stress examined the evidence for the law and found it wanting. It concludes that the law “has no basis in empirical fact”, and it looks at how the simple graph helped the idea spread.
- A 2024 lab study found the upside-down U in people’s moment-to-moment alertness, measured by pupil size. Performance peaked at middle levels in tasks where people spotted or told apart sights and sounds. Its authors note that, before this, the evidence for the curve in humans was “mixed at best”.
The mouse data did show a middle level working best on the hard task, which is part of why the idea feels solid. Our reading: the mouse study is real, but it says less than the curve suggests. Newer lab work supports the curve for alertness in simple tasks. Going from that to stress at work is still a long step, and scholars disagree on how much evidence fills the gap.
Vygotsky’s zone of proximal development
The idea of a zone just beyond what you can already do comes from somewhere else. The psychologist Lev Vygotsky (1896–1934) described a zone of proximal development.
An English edition of his writings, Mind in Society, was edited by Michael Cole and others and published in 1978. There, the zone is the distance between what a learner can solve alone and what they can solve “under adult guidance or in collaboration with more capable peers”. We read that definition as quoted in an introduction to his work, not in the book itself.
The definition says nothing about comfort or fear. Its key idea is help: what becomes possible when someone more capable works with you.
Senninger’s three zones
The three-zone picture comes from Tom Senninger, a German adventure educator. One account dates his learning zone model to 2000, the year his book on leading adventure-based learning came out. Senninger’s model is described as based on Vygotsky’s zone of proximal development, so the link is real. But Vygotsky’s zone is about what a learner can do with help from someone more capable. It says nothing about comfort, fear or panic.
Accounts of his model describe three zones.
- Comfort zone: what’s familiar, where you feel safe. One account calls it important too, as a place to return to, relax and recharge.
- Learning zone: just outside the familiar. Here you’re challenged, and you slowly expand your comfort zone by becoming more familiar with more things.
- Panic zone: beyond the learning zone. In this account, it is where learning is impossible, because fear blocks it.
The same account says “these three zones are different for different situations and different for each person”. So the zones are not a ladder you climb once.
Where the phrase “comfort zone” came from
The phrase is older than any of these models. It was in print by 1923, in research on heating and ventilation. A paper that year for the American Society of Heating and Ventilating Engineers was titled “Determination of the comfort zone”.
Judith Bardwick’s 1991 management book Danger in the Comfort Zone uses it for behaviour at work, and is sometimes named as the phrase’s origin. Her book has the phrase in its title, which may be why it gets the credit.
The four-zone diagram
The version with four rings, for comfort, fear, learning and growth, was online by April 2019: a writer reports seeing it then. That writer looked for its creator and found only people who had reposted it. We couldn’t find the original either.
Some accounts credit the four-zone version to Senninger’s 2000 model. Other accounts we read describe three zones, with panic, not growth, beyond learning. We couldn’t read his book to settle it.
The four-zone version has no panic zone, and it adds a fear zone before learning. It also presents the zones as phases in order, which makes a one-way reading easy. In our reading, that changes the message: fear becomes a stage to push through, rather than a sign that a step may be too big.
We found no study that tests whether people must pass through a fear stage on the way to learning. In a 2022 study of 2,163 adults across five experiments, treating discomfort as a sign of growth made people engage more and feel they had made more progress. The authors write that growth “often requires experiencing discomfort”, and the effect appeared only where growth caused discomfort straight away. That is often, not always, and discomfort is not the same as fear.
Desirable difficulties and deliberate practice
Learning research has its own version of stretch, but not too far: desirable difficulties. These are conditions that make learning feel harder but help it last. In a 2011 chapter, Elizabeth and Robert Bjork give examples:
- varying the conditions of practice instead of keeping them the same;
- mixing topics instead of studying one at a time;
- spacing study sessions out instead of cramming;
- using tests instead of being shown the material again.
Robert Bjork coined the term in 1994. He and Elizabeth Bjork add a limit: a difficulty only helps if the learner has the background to respond to it successfully. Otherwise, it becomes an undesirable difficulty.
Research on expert performance points the same way. Anders Ericsson and Robert Pool describe deliberate practice as “constantly pushing oneself beyond one’s comfort zone”, with activities designed by an expert and feedback to find and fix weaknesses.
So does growth only happen outside your comfort zone? Practice at the edge of your skill matters: deliberate practice points that way. Desirable difficulties add that some kinds of extra difficulty help learning last. But only goes further than the research we found. Accounts of Senninger’s model do put growth in the learning zone, but they give the comfort zone a role too, as a place to recharge and reflect.
Quick answers
Who made the comfort zone diagram?
The three-zone version comes from Tom Senninger, a German adventure educator; one account dates his model to 2000. The four-zone picture, with fear and growth zones, was online by April 2019, and we couldn't find its creator.
Is the Yerkes-Dodson law real?
The 1908 paper is real, but it measured how fast mice learned under electric shocks of different strengths, not anxiety and performance. Whether a bit of stress helps is still argued: a 2015 paper found no empirical basis for the law, and a 2024 lab study found the curve for moment-to-moment alertness in simple tasks.
Does growth only happen outside your comfort zone?
Practice at the edge of your skill matters, and some kinds of extra difficulty help learning last. But a difficulty only helps if you can respond to it, and accounts of the three-zone model give the comfort zone a role too, as a place to recharge.
Who coined the phrase comfort zone?
It was in print by 1923, in research on heating and ventilation. Judith Bardwick's 1991 book Danger in the Comfort Zone uses it for behaviour at work, and is sometimes named as the phrase's origin.
Use this
Size the next step of one task, not your courage.
Where does this next step sit for me: too easy, a stretch, too big, or panic?
Quick quiz
Nothing is scored or saved. Recalling it once now is what makes it last.
1. What did Yerkes and Dodson's 1908 study measure?
Answer: How fast mice learned under electric shocks.Read it again ↑
2. What is the key idea in Vygotsky's zone of proximal development?
Answer: Help from someone more capable.Read it again ↑
3. In the three-zone model, what lies beyond the learning zone?
Answer: Panic.Read it again ↑
How we checked this · Last checked October 2026
- The 1908 paper was read in full at Classics in the History of Psychology (York University); the 2007 review and the 2024 study in full on Europe PMC.
- For Teigen (1994) and Corbett (2015) we read the abstracts.
- Vygotsky's definition was read as quoted in Harry Daniels's An Introduction to Vygotsky, through Open Library's search inside the book. The 1923 paper and Bardwick's book were read through catalogue records and quoted passages.
- We could not read Senninger's 2000 book, so whether he drew a fourth zone is left open.
- We found no study that tests a fear stage, or that sets the 1 to 10 cut-offs, in searches of Europe PMC in October 2026.
- The date the four-zone picture appeared online comes from a business blog post and a 2019 LinkedIn article, which we do not name.
Sources
The 1908 experiment and its retelling
- Robert M. Yerkes and John D. Dodson, “The relation of strength of stimulus to rapidity of habit-formation”, Journal of Comparative Neurology and Psychology 18 (1908), 459–482. Read in full at Classics in the History of Psychology (York University).Primary
- Karl Halvor Teigen, “Yerkes-Dodson: A Law for all Seasons”, Theory & Psychology 4(4) (1994), 525–547, doi:10.1177/0959354394044004.Scholarly
- David M. Diamond, Adam M. Campbell, Collin R. Park, Joshua Halonen and Phillip R. Zoladz, “The temporal dynamics model of emotional memory processing: a synthesis on the neurobiological basis of stress-induced amnesia, flashbulb and traumatic memories, and the Yerkes-Dodson law”, Neural Plasticity (2007).Scholarly
- Martin Corbett, “From law to folklore: work stress and the Yerkes-Dodson Law”, Journal of Managerial Psychology 30(6) (2015), 741–752, doi:10.1108/JMP-03-2013-0085.Scholarly
- L. Beerendonk, J. F. Mejías, S. A. Nuiten, J. W. de Gee, J. J. Fahrenfort and S. van Gaal, “A disinhibitory circuit mechanism explains a general principle of peak performance during mid-level arousal”, PNAS 121(5) (2024), e2312898121.Scholarly
Vygotsky and Senninger
- L. S. Vygotsky, Mind in Society: The Development of Higher Psychological Processes, edited by Michael Cole and others (Harvard University Press, 1978), p. 86, as quoted in Harry Daniels (ed.), An Introduction to Vygotsky (Routledge, 2005), read as short searchable passages through Open Library.Primary
- Library of Congress name authority, “Vygotskiĭ, L. S. (Lev Semenovich), 1896-1934”.Scholarly
- Tom Senninger, Abenteuer leiten – in Abenteuern lernen (Ökotopia, 2000), catalogue record in the German National Library.Primary
- ThemPra Social Pedagogy, “The Learning Zone Model”.Popular
- “Enhancing Medical Education: A Pathway to Nurturing Future Healthcare Professionals”, Cureus (2024), on the three zones.Scholarly
- “Tourists’ apprehension toward choosing the next destination: A study based on the learning zone model”, Frontiers in Psychology (2022), for the date of Senninger’s model.Scholarly
The phrase “comfort zone”
- F. C. Houghten and C. P. Yaglou (Yagloglou), “Determination of the comfort zone”, ASHVE Transactions 29 (1923), 361, as cited in P. O. Fanger, Thermal Comfort and other books, read as short searchable passages through Open Library.Primary
- Judith M. Bardwick, Danger in the Comfort Zone (AMACOM, 1991), catalogue record on Open Library.Primary
Difficulty, practice and discomfort
- Elizabeth L. Bjork and Robert A. Bjork, “Making things hard on yourself, but in a good way: Creating desirable difficulties to enhance learning”, in Psychology and the Real World (2011), pp. 56–64.Scholarly
- Anders Ericsson and Robert Pool, “Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong”, excerpt from Peak, Salon, 10 April 2016.Primary
- Kaitlin Woolley and Ayelet Fishbach, “Motivating Personal Growth by Seeking Discomfort”, Psychological Science 33(4) (2022), 510–523.Scholarly
Plans and progress
- Paschal Sheeran, Olivia Listrom and Peter M. Gollwitzer, “The when and how of planning: Meta-analysis of the scope and components of implementation intentions in 642 tests”, European Review of Social Psychology 36(1) (2025; online 2024), doi:10.1080/10463283.2024.2334563.Scholarly
- Benjamin Harkin et al., “Does monitoring goal progress promote goal attainment? A meta-analysis of the experimental evidence”, Psychological Bulletin 142(2) (2016), 198–229.Scholarly
TRY IT HERE · STAYS IN THIS BROWSER
Find your next stretch
The same steps as the list above. Rate a step, resize it until it feels like a 5 or 6, then add an if-then plan. Your answers stay in this browser and are never sent to us.
My next stretch
ZONES BELONG TO THE TASK- Skill
- Step
- Feels like
- If-then plan
One stretch a week
Once a week, a one-line log: the skill, the step you tried, how hard it felt before and afterwards, and the next step. Over a few weeks it can show a step moving from stretch to easy.
No lines yet. “Add it to my weekly log” saves the step above with how hard it felt before.
Stop asking if you're brave enough
Swap 'Am I brave enough?' for 'Where does my next step sit?' The second question has an answer you can act on today. Size that step well, week after week, and your log will show where you've moved.
Turn one stretch into a habit
- Pick one skill. One skill at a time keeps your effort focused and your log easy to read.
- Book a weekly slot. Choose one fixed time each week to size your next step and log the last one.
- Try help before shrinking. If a step feels too big, ask whether a teacher or partner could make it a stretch first.
- Keep the step, not the goal, moving. A big goal can stay big. Only this week's step gets smaller or harder.
- Size up when it gets easy. When a step you once rated 5 or 6 feels easy, find the next one. The 1–10 scale is our rule of thumb.
- Read your log after a few weeks. Steps that moved from stretch to easy show the zone growing, as the three-zone model describes.
Goes with: A redrawn diagram: the zones belong to the task ↑
This week: one stretch, tried and logged
Find one step that rates a 5 or 6 in the stretch finder. Give it an if-then plan and try it before the week ends. Then write one line: the step, how hard it felt before and after, and what comes next.
Coach a friend or a team the same way
- Ask about the step. 'How hard does this feel, 1 to 10?' is easier to answer honestly than 'Are you brave enough?'
- Resize together. Shrink a step that scares them. Add a small challenge to one that bores them.
- Be the help. Help from someone more capable can bring a step within reach. Your support counts as part of their stretch.
- Read panic as a sizing signal. In the three-zone model, the panic zone is where fear blocks learning, and the model's answer is a smaller step. If someone's fear goes beyond the task, a doctor or mental-health professional is the right person to talk to.
- Give each person their own step. The zones differ for each situation and each person, so one team-wide challenge won't fit everyone.
Already good at something? Teach it this way
- Tutor or coach a skill you know well. Plan each session around one step your learner rates a 5 or 6.
- Offer practice as the patient partner: a chat in a language you speak well, or a friendly first audience.
- If you work in a field people want to enter, offer short calls about the work. In the worked examples on this page, a talk with someone who does the work is a stretch step.
Ideas to explore, not financial or business advice. No result is promised.