Skip to content

Motivation

10 min left
BOOK SUMMARY · GRIT

Grit Summary: The Key Ideas, What Holds Up, and How to Use Them

Angela Duckworth's case for passion and perseverance, and what later research found.

Hacks Vitae artwork (AI-assisted)
The answer

Grit argues that what people achieve depends less on talent than we assume and more on grit: passion and perseverance for long-term goals.

It suits readers wanting an encouraging account of staying power. Grit does predict some outcomes, but modestly, and whether it is more than conscientiousness is still argued.

Why it mattersKnowing how big grit's effects really are keeps one score from deciding what you think of a person.

Key facts
  1. Talent vs gritGrit predicted success beyond IQ, but modestly.
  2. Effort counts twiceTalent × effort = skill; skill × effort = achievement. No test found.
  3. Two halvesPerseverance predicts outcomes better than consistency of interest.
  4. Grit can growSome evidence, mostly for children; not settled.
  5. The settingTeacher support predicted graduation in the Chicago study.
  6. Not enough aloneDuckworth writes that grit is necessary but not sufficient.

By Hacks Vitae Published Updated Last checked October 2026 10 min read 19 sources ↓

Start hereIn Duckworth's studies, grit predicted which West Point cadets stayed through summer training. Yet about 94% of cadets completed it anyway. So how much does grit add?

About the book

Grit is a best-selling book built on its author’s own research, and that research has been argued over in print. Grit: The Power of Passion and Perseverance is by Angela Duckworth. She is a psychologist who is the Rosa Lee and Egbert Chang Professor at the University of Pennsylvania and a 2013 MacArthur Fellow.

Scribner published it in New York in 2016, at 333 pages plus xv pages of front matter. Her website calls it a #1 New York Times best seller.

It is popular psychology for a general reader, built on her own research. Part I explains what grit is and why she thinks it matters. Part II is about growing grit from the inside out, through interest, practice, purpose and hope. Part III is about growing it from the outside in, through parenting, activities and the culture around you.

We are distracted by talent

Duckworth argues that people overrate natural talent when they explain success, and underrate staying power. In her 2013 TED talk she said that “in our data, grit is usually unrelated or even inversely related to measures of talent”.

One of her examples is West Point. In Duckworth’s studies, grit predicted which cadets stayed through summer training. The book says West Point’s own admissions score did not reliably predict it.

Does it hold up? Yes, but modestly: grit does predict success beyond talent. The 2007 paper found grit did not relate positively to IQ and still predicted outcomes beyond it. But grit accounted for an average of 4% of the variance in success outcomes.

In a 2014 study of 4,813 Chicago high school juniors, those one standard deviation higher in grit had 21% higher odds of graduating on time. That was after controlling for test scores, school conditions and background. Grit on its own added 0.50% to the variance the model explained, against 4.03% for test scores.

A 2017 meta-analysis of 88 samples and 66,807 people found grit only moderately correlated with performance and retention. It said these links “do not compare favorably” with better-known predictors such as cognitive ability. Grit’s measured effects are real but small, so a grit score says little about any one person’s future.

The West Point figure is smaller than it sounds. Credé and colleagues pointed out that a 2009 paper read an odds ratio of 1.99 as cadets being “99% more likely to complete summer training”.

About 94% of cadets completed it anyway. With a base rate that high, a doubling of the odds is a small change in the chance of finishing.

Effort counts twice

Her model has two steps: talent times effort gives skill, and skill times effort gives achievement. Effort appears in both, which is the point of the chapter title. Her website defines talent narrowly, as “the rate at which a person improves in skill”.

Does it hold up? We can’t confirm it as a formula. We found no study that tests the two equations as stated. The nearest evidence is on practice.

A 2014 meta-analysis, as corrected by its authors in 2018, measured how much of the differences in performance deliberate practice explained. It was 24% in games, 23% in music and 20% in sports, but 5% in education and 1% in professions.

Ericsson replied that it had defined deliberate practice much more broadly than he had.

Grit is passion plus perseverance

She defines grit as “passion and perseverance for long-term goals”. Passion here means steady commitment to one top-level goal over years, not intensity in the moment. Perseverance means working hard through setbacks. The book includes a short Grit Scale so readers can rate themselves.

Does it hold up? Partly: the two halves behave differently. The 2017 meta-analysis found that grit’s higher-order structure was not confirmed. Perseverance of effort predicted outcomes better than consistency of interest.

A 2019 study of 7,617 people in many countries found perseverance linked to well-being and strengths, while consistency of interests had weak or negative links.

On the other side, a 2018 study combining 127 studies found grit’s link with performance was larger where people were more passionate about the field. It argued that the Grit Scale captures perseverance but not passion.

In 2021 Duckworth and two colleagues acknowledged “our error in interpretation” of the scale’s factor structure. They argued that whether grit is one thing is a conceptual question, not one a questionnaire can settle. They still treat grit as a compound of passion and perseverance.

Her website also sets limits on the scale. It says you can fake a higher score “without much effort” and that scores carry “reference bias”. It says the scale is not appropriate for selecting employees, admitting students or comparing schools.

Try it: Duckworth’s own limits on the Grit Scale are worth keeping in mind: it is a tool for reflection and research, not for judging people.

Grit can grow

She argues that grit is not fixed. From the inside, it grows through four psychological assets: interest, practice, purpose and hope.

The practice she means is deliberate practice, a term she takes from K. A. Ericsson, a co-author of her 2011 spelling bee study. It means a clearly defined stretch goal on one narrow part of a skill, worked at with full concentration. It is often not enjoyable.

Does the practice part hold up? In her spelling bee studies, yes. Grittier spellers went further at the National Spelling Bee, and practised more.

In a 2011 study, deliberate practice, here studying and memorising words alone, predicted performance better than being quizzed or reading for pleasure. It also mediated the link between grit and final performance: a statistical link in one group of spellers, not a controlled test.

The spellers rated that practice the most effortful and least enjoyable kind. Ericsson, a co-author, later set the study aside as evidence of deliberate practice in his strict sense. It had not recorded a teacher or coach supervising the spellers’ practice, according to a 2020 review.

Does grit itself grow? Partly: there is some evidence, mostly for children, and it is not settled. Older people score slightly higher on grit, a pattern the 2017 meta-analysis compares to the general rise in conscientiousness with age.

A 2016 twin study estimated the heritability of the perseverance part at 37%, which leaves room for experience. It found no evidence of shared environmental influence, meaning the part of the environment twins share, such as home.

A 2018 study co-written by Duckworth called how to encourage grit in students “an open question”. A randomised classroom programme in two elementary school samples, published in 2019, found effects on effort and about 0.2 standard deviations on a maths test 2.5 years later.

Against that, a 2018 review found no support then for the claim that grit is likely to respond to interventions. Duckworth said in 2013 that science knows little about how to build it.

A 2024 review of training programmes for health-professions students pooled two controlled studies of grit training. The estimated benefit was about half a standard deviation, but the range of plausible results ran from slightly negative to large. The authors called the evidence preliminary.

Try it: spend part of your practice time on focused, solitary work on the hardest part, not only on the kinds you enjoy.

The setting shapes it too

From the outside, grit grows through parents, coaches and the groups people belong to. Her own family uses a Hard Thing Rule. Everyone does something that takes deliberate practice. You can quit, but not in the middle of a season or on a bad day. And you get to pick your own hard thing.

In the Chicago study, school safety and teacher support also predicted graduation when each was looked at on its own. Teacher support still did once everything else was controlled for.

Try it: when someone is struggling, look at the setting as well as the person.

Grit is not the only thing that matters

On her website Duckworth writes that “Grit is necessary but not sufficient”. She adds that opportunity, mentors and support matter. If she had to choose for her children, she would choose honesty and kindness over grit.

What holds up, and what the book overstates

What the sources show for each idea

01 At West Point, grit was what mattered for getting through the first summerCredited to The book Partly Grit predicted it, but about 94% of cadets finished anyway, so the gain is small. Evidence ↓
02 Grit predicts success over and above talent Holds up True in her studies, but small: an average of 4% of the variance. Evidence ↓
03 Grit is a different trait from conscientiousnessCredited to Angela Duckworth Still argued Duckworth holds they differ; independent studies find a large overlap. Evidence ↓
04 Passion and perseverance work together as one trait Partly The two halves behave differently; perseverance predicts outcomes better. Evidence ↓
05 Grittier spellers went further at the National Spelling Bee, and practised more Holds up Found in her spelling bee studies; a statistical link, not a controlled test. Evidence ↓
06 Grit can grow Partly Some evidence, mostly for children; reviews disagree and it is not settled. Evidence ↓
07 Effort counts twice: talent × effort = skill, and skill × effort = achievement Can't confirm No test of the equations found; deliberate practice explained 24% of performance differences in games, 1% in professions. Evidence ↓

Some of the book’s findings hold up in their own samples: grittier spellers practised more and went further, and grit predicted who stayed in several hard programmes. The bigger claims have had a harder time. Grit predicts outcomes, but modestly, and it overlaps heavily with conscientiousness, a long-studied personality trait.

Is grit more than conscientiousness?

It is a genuine disagreement. Here are both sides and where the evidence leans.

Duckworth’s case. Her website says grit and conscientiousness are related but not the same trait. It says grit “predicts achieving challenging goals even when these other characteristics are held constant”. Her 2007 paper found grit “highly correlated with Big Five Conscientiousness” but still predicting success beyond it and beyond IQ.

The case for a large overlap. Credé, Tynan and Harms (2017) pooled 88 samples in all. In the 22 that measured both traits, they estimated the correlation between grit and conscientiousness at .84 after correcting for measurement error (.66 before correction).

Once conscientiousness was taken into account, overall grit explained no variance in high school grades and very little in college grades.

A UK twin study of 4,642 16-year-olds (Rimfeld and colleagues, 2016) found that personality, mainly conscientiousness, predicted about 6% of the variance in GCSE exam grades. Grit “adds little” to that. It found the perseverance part and conscientiousness “to a large extent the same trait”.

Ponnock and colleagues (2020) concluded that the two “are not unique constructs”.

Where it leans. Three independent teams, using a meta-analysis, a large twin sample and item-level analysis, all found heavy overlap. Our reading: the overlap is large, and any part of grit that adds something is mostly perseverance. The 2017 meta-analysis found perseverance still explained variance in academic performance after controlling for conscientiousness.

Who it’s for, and who can skip it

It suits readers who want an encouraging account of why staying power matters, and parents, teachers and coaches looking for language about effort and practice. Its central attitude, keep going at something that matters to you, is reasonable.

The claims that grit is a distinct trait that beats talent are stronger in the book than in the research that followed. Readers who know the research on conscientiousness and deliberate practice will find much of it familiar.

Quick answers

What is grit, according to Angela Duckworth?

She defines grit as passion and perseverance for long-term goals. Passion means steady commitment to one top-level goal over years; perseverance means working hard through setbacks.

Is grit the same as conscientiousness?

It is still argued. Duckworth holds they differ; the 2017 review put their correlation at .84 after correcting for measurement error, and a 2016 twin study found grit added little to predicting exam grades. Our reading: the overlap is large, and any part of grit that adds something is mostly perseverance.

Does grit predict success?

Yes, but modestly. In Duckworth's own studies it accounted for an average of 4% of the variance in success outcomes, and a 2017 review of 88 samples found it only moderately correlated with performance and retention.

Can you increase your grit?

There is some evidence, mostly for children, and it is not settled. A randomised classroom programme found effects on effort, while a 2018 review found no support then for the claim that grit is likely to respond to interventions.

Can the Grit Scale be used to hire people?

Duckworth's website says the scale is not appropriate for selecting employees, admitting students or comparing schools, and that you can fake a higher score without much effort.

Use this

The lesson

Keep going at what matters to you, and judge the effort, not a score.

The rule

Am I practising the hard part, or only the part I enjoy?

Quick quiz

Three questions, thirty seconds

Nothing is scored or saved. Recalling it once now is what makes it last.

1. What correlation did the 2017 meta-analysis find between grit and conscientiousness, after correcting for measurement error?

Answer: Very high, .84.Read it again ↑

2. In the spelling bee study, which preparation predicted performance best?

Answer: Studying and memorising words alone.Read it again ↑

3. Why is the West Point grit figure smaller than it sounds?

Answer: About 94% of cadets completed the training anyway.Read it again ↑

How we checked this · Last checked October 2026
  • What we read of the book: the library catalogue record of the 2016 Scribner edition and passages found through the Internet Archive's search-inside tool, plus Duckworth's website and her 2013 TED talk transcript.
  • For the studies we read the abstracts, plus the full texts of the 2014 Chicago study, the 2017 meta-analysis and the 2020 review of deliberate practice.
  • Grit versus conscientiousness is a genuine disagreement: the page gives Duckworth's case and the independent studies, and labels our reading.
  • We found no study that tests the book's two effort equations as stated.

How we check every article →

Sources

Primary written at the time, by a witness, or the original text Scholarly edited or peer-reviewed work Popular press, blogs and general websites