Skip to content

Tools & Tech

10 min left
CHECKED · FILE FORMATS

Does Opening a JPEG Lose Quality? 12 File Format Beliefs and What the Documentation Says

Twelve beliefs about JPEG, PNG, HEIC, WebP, AVIF and PDF files, set beside the documentation.

Hacks Vitae artwork (AI-assisted)

Prices, versions and facts as of October 2026.

The answer

No: opening a JPEG does not change it; quality is lost when a JPEG is saved again, because each lossy save compresses it once more.

Web images do not need 72 dpi either, since by default browsers size images by their pixels. For HEIC, WebP, AVIF and PDFs, the answer depends on the device, browser or tool.

Why it mattersThese rules decide how files get saved and shared, so a wrong one can quietly cost quality or privacy.

Our verdicts
  • 8Doesn't hold up
  • 4Partly

See every verdict →

By Hacks Vitae Published Updated Last checked October 2026 10 min read 19 sources ↓

Start hereOpening a JPEG to look at it does not change it. Yet a JPEG saved again and again does lose quality, round after round. So which file-format rules hold up?

Some rules about image and file formats were true once, some are true in one program, and some were never true at all. Below, twelve common beliefs about JPEG, PNG, HEIC, WebP, AVIF and PDF files are set against format specifications, official documentation and published tests.

Where one of the site’s free tools fits, a section ends with a link to it. The image converters linked here run in your browser and do not upload your files, as each tool’s own page explains.

The verdicts

01 A JPEG loses quality every time you open itCredited to Popular belief Doesn't hold up Opening changes nothing; each new save compresses the picture again, a Library of Congress post explains. Evidence ↓
02 Images for the web must be 72 dpiCredited to Popular belief Doesn't hold up By default browsers size images by their pixels; no rule requires 72 dpi. Evidence ↓
03 PNG is always better quality than JPEGCredited to Popular belief Partly PNG is lossless, but MDN recommends lossy formats for photographs. Evidence ↓
04 Converting a JPEG to PNG restores lost qualityCredited to Popular belief Doesn't hold up The PNG copies the JPEG's pixels, artefacts included; lost detail cannot come back. Evidence ↓
05 HEIC only works on Apple devicesCredited to Popular belief Doesn't hold up Android lists decoding from 9.0 on devices that support it; Windows reads it with extensions. Evidence ↓
06 WebP is supported by every browserCredited to Popular belief Partly Every current major browser; Internet Explorer never did, and Macs need Safari 14 and Big Sur. Evidence ↓
07 AVIF is always smaller than WebPCredited to Popular belief Partly Smaller in a 2020 lossy test of 600 images; larger in a 2021 lossless test. Evidence ↓
08 PDFs can't be editedCredited to Popular belief Doesn't hold up Word converts a copy for editing; Preview changes pages and markup, not the text. Evidence ↓
09 Screenshots are always PNGCredited to Popular belief Doesn't hold up On supported Macs with macOS Tahoe 26, choosing HDR capture saves screenshots as HEIF, not PNG. Evidence ↓
10 Removing EXIF removes all identifying dataCredited to Popular belief Doesn't hold up IIM and XMP metadata, sensor noise and the picture itself can remain. Evidence ↓
11 Photos you post online always keep their location dataCredited to Popular belief Doesn't hold up It depends on the service and your settings; Apple's share sheet can leave location out. Evidence ↓
12 Compressing a PDF always lowers its qualityCredited to Popular belief Partly Presets that resample images lower quality; structural tools such as qpdf preserve content. Evidence ↓
6 of 12 shown · a mix of every verdict
Doesn't hold up

“A JPEG loses quality every time you open it”

Credited to Popular belief

Doesn't hold up Opening a JPEG to look at it does not change it; the loss comes when a JPEG is saved again.

The loss itself is real. JPEG’s usual mode throws detail away to make files small. MDN’s guide to image formats calls JPEG the most widely used lossy compression format for still images.

A 2013 Library of Congress post on personal digital archiving explains when that loss happens. Each new save compresses the picture again, and after multiple rounds of changes and re-compression, the post says, you would begin to see the image degrade. If you don’t intend to change a JPEG, the same post says you can archive it as it is.

The guide Lossy vs. lossless compression explains the difference in plain words.

↑ All verdicts
Doesn't hold up

“Images for the web must be 72 dpi”

Credited to Popular belief

Doesn't hold up On a screen, an image’s size comes from its pixel dimensions and the page’s layout.

It’s easy to see why dpi seems to matter: image files can store a value for it. But by default, MDN explains, browsers assume one device pixel equals one CSS pixel. In that case an image’s natural, or intrinsic, size is simply its pixel height and width.

MDN adds that an image’s intrinsic size and resolution can be explicitly set in its EXIF data, details about the image stored inside the file. So a browser can use stored resolution information in some cases. Neither case makes 72 dpi a rule for the web.

A dpi setting is a note about physical size; it does not change how many pixels a picture has. The PNG specification stores it as pixels per unit, which give the intended pixel size or aspect ratio for display of the image. For what printers ask for, see our business card basics page.

The site’s free image resizer reduces an image’s pixel width in your browser, which is what changes its size on screen.

↑ All verdicts
Partly

“PNG is always better quality than JPEG”

Credited to Popular belief

Partly PNG keeps every pixel exactly as it was given, but that doesn’t make it the better choice for every picture.

The W3C specification describes PNG as a format for lossless, portable, well-compressed storage of images. Lossless means the original data can be rebuilt exactly, bit for bit, which JPEG’s usual mode does not allow.

Whether it is better still depends on the picture. MDN recommends lossless encoding for screenshots, diagrams, logos and line art, where blurring around text is very visible. Photographs, it says, can usually take lossy compression, because the lost detail is harder to see.

A PNG is also only as good as the pixels handed to it. Tools such as pngquant offer lossy compression of PNG images by first reducing the picture to a palette. A palette is a list of colours that each pixel points to, and in the PNG specification it holds from 1 to 256 entries. The result is still a PNG, but colours were merged before it was written.

The site’s image format benchmark encodes your own picture as JPG and WebP at several quality settings, plus one lossless PNG, in your browser, and reports the real file sizes.

↑ All verdicts
Doesn't hold up

“Converting a JPEG to PNG restores the lost quality”

Credited to Popular belief

Doesn't hold up A PNG made from a JPEG is an exact copy of the JPEG’s pixels, artefacts included. It can’t add back detail the JPEG already threw away.

The idea makes sense at first glance, because PNG is lossless. But lossless only means nothing more is lost: it keeps what it is given. The Library of Congress post says of compression loss that once that digital information is lost, you can never get it back.

The site’s JPG to PNG converter says the same on its own page. The guide How to convert JPG to PNG without losing quality covers when converting still makes sense.

↑ All verdicts
Doesn't hold up

“HEIC only works on Apple devices”

Credited to Popular belief

Doesn't hold up Android can read HEIC files too, on devices that support it, and so can Windows with Microsoft’s extensions, though most web browsers can’t.

The link to Apple is real. HEIC files use HEIF, and Apple’s devices took up HEIF when iOS 11 and macOS High Sierra introduced support for it. Apple itself calls it an industry-standard format. Apple says HEIF and HEVC offer better compression than JPEG and H.264, using less storage while preserving the same visual quality.

Other systems read HEIC too:

Where HEIC still runs into trouble is the web. In caniuse’s browser data, read on 5 October 2026, Safari from version 17 is the only browser listed as supporting HEIF images.

Apple also notes what happens when you share by AirDrop, Messages or email and the receiving device does not support the format. In that case, Apple says, the media might automatically be shared in a more compatible format, such as JPEG or H.264.

If a HEIC will not open somewhere, the site’s HEIC to JPG converter converts it inside your browser tab. The guide Why won’t HEIC open on Windows and Android? covers each platform.

↑ All verdicts
Partly

“WebP is supported by every browser”

Credited to Popular belief

Partly Every current major browser displays WebP, with two gaps. MDN lists support in Chrome, Edge, Firefox, Opera and Safari.

Internet Explorer never supported it, according to caniuse’s data. And on a Mac, MDN notes, WebP support depends on both the Safari and macOS versions. You need Safari 14 or later, and macOS Big Sur (11) or later.

The site’s WebP to JPG converter turns a WebP into a JPG in your browser when something will not take a WebP.

↑ All verdicts
Partly

“AVIF is always smaller than WebP”

Credited to Popular belief

Partly For lossy images AVIF usually comes out smaller than WebP, but one test of lossless images found the opposite.

MDN says AVIF generally compresses better than WebP: a median 50% compression against 30% for the same set of JPG files. It cites a 2020 comparison by Daniel Aleksandersen.

In that test of 600 images at the same measured visual quality, AVIF’s median file was 50.3% smaller than the reference JPEG and WebP’s 31.5% smaller. AVIF beat both JPEG and WebP on every image in the test.

Lossless images are a different story. Johannes Siipola tested 94 images in a 2021 blog post, mostly designs of websites, apps, logos and illustrations. He found lossless AVIF files noticeably larger than WebP or JPEG XL.

Both tests are from 2020 and 2021, so their exact figures are a snapshot of the encoders of the time.

The guide WebP vs. AVIF vs. JPG compares the three formats. The image format benchmark measures JPG, WebP and PNG (not AVIF) on your own files.

↑ All verdicts
Doesn't hold up

“PDFs can’t be edited”

Credited to Popular belief

Doesn't hold up PDFs can be edited, though how much depends on the program.

The belief has a point. Apple’s Preview on the Mac lets you add, delete and rearrange pages and mark a PDF up. But Apple’s guide says plainly that you can’t edit the text of a PDF in Preview.

Word goes further: Microsoft’s instructions say that to edit a PDF, you open it in Word. Word makes a copy of the PDF and converts its contents. This works best with PDFs that are mostly text, and lines and pages may break at different locations.

So what you can change depends on the tool: pages and notes in one, the text itself after a conversion in another.

The site’s organise PDF tool rotates, deletes and reorders pages in your browser, and split PDF pulls out the pages you list into a new file.

↑ All verdicts
Doesn't hold up

“Screenshots are always PNG”

Credited to Popular belief

Doesn't hold up Many screenshots are PNG, but not all. On supported Macs with macOS Tahoe 26 or later, Apple’s Screenshot app lets you choose the capture format. Standard dynamic range captures use PNG, and high dynamic range captures use HEIF.

The belief has a good reason behind it: PNG suits most screen content. MDN recommends lossless encoding for screenshots, because blurring around text is easy to see.

The site’s PNG to JPG converter converts a PNG screenshot in your browser, and its page explains why sharp text is often better left as PNG.

↑ All verdicts
Doesn't hold up

“Removing EXIF removes all identifying data”

Credited to Popular belief

Doesn't hold up EXIF is one store of hidden data in a photo, not the only one.

IPTC, which describes itself as the global standards body of the news media, tests what photo-sharing sites keep. Its tests check for embedded EXIF metadata, and for IPTC metadata in the formats IIM and XMP. So removing EXIF alone can leave the IIM and XMP fields in place.

A camera can also leave a trace in the pixels themselves. In a 2006 paper, three researchers described a way to use the pattern of noise from a camera’s sensor as a unique fingerprint for that camera. They tested it on about 320 images taken with nine consumer digital cameras. They also studied how its error rates change after common processing such as JPEG compression.

And what a picture shows travels with it, whatever happens to the metadata.

The site’s EXIF remover writes a new file from the pixels alone, so no embedded metadata comes with it. It cannot change what the picture shows.

↑ All verdicts
Doesn't hold up

“Photos you post online always keep their location data”

Credited to Popular belief

Doesn't hold up Whether a posted photo keeps its location depends on the service and on your settings.

The worry is reasonable. When location is on, Apple explains, the camera’s coordinates are embedded into each photo and video. The people you share them with may be able to access the location metadata.

What happens next depends on where the photo goes. Some services remove metadata from the copies they show. Others pass the original file along.

IPTC’s tests, published in 2019, show how differently services treat embedded metadata. They checked whether caption, creator, rights and other embedded fields survived, not location in particular.

Facebook’s saved copies had no XMP metadata, though a few rights-related fields were kept. Dropbox passed the original file through, and Flickr let people download the original. Services change how they handle files, so a 2019 test tells you what happened then, not what happens today.

Apple’s share sheet has a switch for this: tap Options, turn off Location, and Photos shows “Location Not Included”.

The guide Does converting an image remove its metadata? explains what a photo can carry.

↑ All verdicts
Partly

“Compressing a PDF always lowers its quality”

Credited to Popular belief

Partly Compressors that shrink the pictures inside a PDF can lower its quality; ones that only rewrite the file’s structure do not.

Some tools only rewrite a file’s structure: qpdf, an open-source PDF program and library, describes its work as structural changes that preserve a PDF’s content.

Other tools shrink the pictures inside. Ghostscript’s documentation warns that its PDFSETTINGS presets alter the input, and so may give a PDF of poorer quality. Its /screen preset selects low-resolution output.

So a compressor that resamples images to a lower resolution lowers their quality; one that only rewrites structure does not.

The site’s PDF compressor is the structural kind: its page says photos and scanned pages are “Not re-encoded, not reduced in resolution”.

↑ All verdicts

Quick answers

Does opening a JPEG lose quality?

No. Opening a JPEG to look at it does not change it. The loss comes when a JPEG is saved again: each new save compresses the picture again, and after multiple rounds, a Library of Congress post says, you would begin to see the image degrade.

Do images for the web need to be 72 dpi?

No. By default, browsers treat an image's natural size as its pixel height and width, so the dpi value does not set its size on screen. A dpi setting is a note about physical size, which matters on paper.

Does converting a JPEG to PNG improve its quality?

No. A PNG made from a JPEG is an exact copy of the JPEG's pixels, artefacts included. PNG is lossless, so nothing more is lost, but it cannot bring back detail the JPEG already threw away.

Can Android and Windows open HEIC files?

Yes, though not everywhere. Android's table of supported formats lists HEIF decoding from Android 9.0 and marks it device optional. Windows reads HEIF with Microsoft's HEIF Image Extension, plus the HEVC Video Extensions for .heic files.

Does removing EXIF data make a photo anonymous?

Not on its own. IPTC metadata can sit in the IIM and XMP formats, separately from EXIF, and a 2006 paper described using the noise pattern of a camera's sensor as a fingerprint. What the picture shows travels with it too.

Use this

The lesson

Before you convert, compress or share a file, ask what that step does to it.

The rule

Will this step save the picture again, who will open it, and what else does the file carry?

Quick quiz

Three questions, thirty seconds

Nothing is scored or saved. Recalling it once now is what makes it last.

1. When does a JPEG lose quality?

Answer: When it is saved again.Read it again ↑

2. By default, what sets an image's size on a screen?

Answer: Its pixel dimensions.Read it again ↑

3. Which kind of PDF compressor preserves a PDF's content?

Answer: One that only rewrites the file's structure.Read it again ↑

How we checked this · Last checked October 2026
  • Each specification and help page was first read on 5 October 2026, and the quoted passages were checked again on 13 October 2026. Android's supported-formats page had changed on 7 October: it now lists HEIF decoding from Android 9.0, marked device optional.
  • caniuse's browser data was read on its site on 5 October 2026 and in its published data files on 13 October 2026; both list Safari 17 and later as the only browser supporting HEIF.
  • For the 2006 camera-identification paper we read the abstract only.
  • The AVIF and WebP size tests date from 2020 and 2021; newer encoders may give different sizes.
  • What each of this site's tools does is taken from the tool's own page, re-read on 13 October 2026.

How we check every article →

Sources

Primary written at the time, by a witness, or the original text Scholarly edited or peer-reviewed work Popular press, blogs and general websites

Formats and specifications

HEIC, WebP and AVIF

PDF

Screenshots, metadata and location

Put it to work
Our take

Set up a routine once, not a fix each time

The same problems keep coming back: a re-saved JPEG, a HEIC that won't open, a photo shared with hidden data. A short routine heads many of them off. Our view: write yours down once and reuse it.

Goes with: 1. “A JPEG loses quality every time you open it” ↑

Steps

A file routine you can reuse

  1. Keep the originals untouched. Store the source files in their own folder. Edit copies, so the original never gets saved again.
  2. Export once, at the end. If the result will be a JPEG, edit a lossless copy. Save to JPEG once, as the last step.
  3. Size screen images in pixels. Set the pixel width the page will show. Save dpi questions for print.
  4. Choose by what's in the picture. Lossless for screenshots, logos and line art. Photographs can usually take a lossy format such as JPEG.
  5. Send what the receiver can open. If someone can't open a HEIC or WebP, send them a JPEG copy and keep yours as it was.
  6. Check before you post. Look at what the file carries besides the picture, and what the picture itself shows.

Goes with: 4. “Converting a JPEG to PNG restores the lost quality” ↑

This week

This week: check one photo before you share it

Pick one photo you plan to post. See whether location is on for your camera, and turn it off in the share options if you can. Then look at what the picture itself shows.

Goes with: 11. “Photos you post online always keep their location data” ↑

Tools

Free tools for each step, in your browser

  • Image resizerReduces an image's pixel width, which is what changes its size on screen.
  • Image format benchmarkEncodes your own picture as JPG, WebP and PNG and reports the real file sizes.
  • HEIC to JPGFor a HEIC that won't open somewhere, converted inside your browser tab.
  • EXIF removerWrites a new file from the pixels alone. It cannot change what the picture shows.
  • PDF compressorThe structural kind: photos and scanned pages are not re-encoded or reduced in resolution.

Goes with: 5. “HEIC only works on Apple devices” ↑

Earn with it

Turn file know-how into a small service

  • Prepare photos for small business websites: the right pixel size, a sensible format and a smaller file.
  • Help a family or a club sort and archive its photos, keeping the originals untouched.
  • Clean metadata from photos before clients publish them, and explain what removing it can't hide.
  • Write a one-page image guide for the volunteers who update a club's or charity's website.

Ideas to explore, not financial or business advice. No result is promised.

Goes with: 10. “Removing EXIF removes all identifying data” ↑