Start hereIn Langer's photocopier study, an empty reason after "because" worked almost as well as a real one for a five-page favour. For twenty pages, the empty reason did no better than none. So which of the book's techniques hold up?
About the book
Influence is by Robert B. Cialdini, Regents’ Professor Emeritus of Psychology and Marketing at Arizona State University. William Morrow first published it in 1984 as Influence: How and Why People Agree to Things. The 1993 edition carried the subtitle The Psychology of Persuasion. A textbook version, Influence: Science and Practice, has been published alongside it.
The 2021 New and Expanded edition adds a seventh principle, unity. It is written for general readers and mixes experiments with everyday examples. In the author’s own description of the 2021 edition, it shows how the principles work and how to defend yourself against unethical influence attempts.
We run on shortcuts
Cialdini’s starting point is that people often respond to a single cue instead of weighing all the information, much as some animals react to one trigger. He calls these automatic responses “click, whirr”. An early example in the book is a study in which a stranger asked to jump the queue at a photocopier.
Does it hold up? Only for a small favour, and repeat attempts disagree. In Ellen Langer’s 1978 photocopier study, asking to copy five pages worked 60% of the time with no reason. It worked 93% of the time with an empty reason (“because I have to make copies”) and 94% with a real one.
For twenty pages, the empty reason did no better than none (24% each), while the real reason got 42%. The small groups held about fifteen people each. The authors reported the large-favour gap only as a trend, in groups of about 25.
Two 1985 studies by Valerie Folkes did not replicate the result; a 2009 study by Key and colleagues did.
Try it: when you ask for something, give the real reason. It was the one version of the “because” effect that did not fall flat when the favour grew.
Reciprocity
People feel obliged to give back what they have received first: a gift, a favour, a concession. One tactic the book describes is what it calls the rejection-then-retreat technique, better known as the door in the face. Ask for something large, and when it is turned down, retreat to the smaller thing you wanted, which feels like a concession to be repaid.
Does it hold up? More people say yes; the effect on what they then do is smaller. Cialdini and colleagues’ 1975 experiments found the big-then-small sequence produced more compliance with the smaller favour, and a 2021 direct replication found compliance rates similar to the original’s.
Try it: if you agreed to something on the spot after turning down a bigger request, look at it again later, before you act on it.
Commitment and consistency
Once people have taken a stand, they tend to act in line with it. The book’s examples include the foot in the door, where agreeing to a small request makes a later, larger one easier to accept. Another is the low-ball, where a deal agreed at one price tends to survive a small increase in the cost.
Does the foot in the door hold up? It can work, but the effect is small and inconsistent. The classic 1966 study by Freedman and Fraser is the book’s example. A 1999 review by Jerry Burger argued that the processes involved can explain both successful demonstrations and studies in which the technique was ineffective or even lowered compliance.
Does the low-ball hold up? Yes, in published studies. A 2015 meta-analysis of published low-ball studies found the procedure “a reliable and effective method for increasing compliance”. It works best when people state their first agreement publicly and when the second cost is only slightly higher. It covered published studies only.
Try it: when extras appear after you have said yes to a deal, look again at the full price.
Social proof
When unsure what to do, people look at what others like them are doing. Cialdini and colleagues later tested this with hotel signs telling guests that most other guests reused their towels.
Does it hold up? Researchers disagree on how strong the evidence is. In the original 2008 study, co-written by Cialdini, the message about other guests beat the standard environmental message (44.1% against 35.1% reuse in one experiment).
Five later replication experiments that measured how many guests reused their towels each failed to reach significance. Among them, a 2014 German study found the norm message no more effective than the standard one. A separate 2014 study in two hotels, which counted towels used, found guests used significantly fewer towels when the message described what other guests in their own situation had done.
A 2016 Bayesian analysis that pooled all seven experiments found strong evidence for the effect. Critics argued the pooling was flawed, and that models allowing the studies to differ weaken the evidence. The authors agreed that analysing the studies separately suited this case better, and replied that averaging across models still gave fairly constant evidence in its favour.
Our reading: a real but small effect over the standard message is likelier, since the pooled evidence points that way and no single study was strong on its own.
Liking
People say yes more readily to those they like. The author’s own summary names three causes of liking: similarity, compliments, and working together towards shared goals.
Authority
People tend to follow credible, knowledgeable experts, and outward signs of authority, such as diplomas on the wall and uniforms, can sway people too. The book discusses Stanley Milgram’s obedience experiments over several pages.
Does it hold up? The obedience held up; the explanation is argued over. In Stanley Milgram’s 1963 study, 26 of 40 participants gave what they believed was the highest shock.
Across the 21 versions of the experiment in which obedience meant going to the maximum shock, 43.6% of 740 people did, so how many obey depends heavily on the set-up. A 2006 partial replication, stopped at 150 volts for ethical reasons, found obedience only slightly lower than Milgram’s.
A 2015 study of Milgram’s archive argues that participants went on because they identified with what they took to be a worthwhile scientific project. That account is at odds with Milgram’s own explanation. A 2020 re-analysis found that in 18 of 23 versions of the experiment, those who fully believed the shocks were real gave lower shocks on average.
Try it: before following an expert, ask what they know about this particular question, and what they gain from your answer.
Scarcity
Does it hold up? Supported, mostly in what people say they want. In a 1975 experiment, cookies in scarce supply were rated more desirable than the same cookies in abundant supply.
A 2022 meta-analysis of 416 effect sizes from 131 studies starts from the finding that scarcity cues generally raise a product’s value and the intention to buy it. It maps which kinds of scarcity work best for which products. Both measure ratings and intentions rather than actual purchases.
Try it: when you see a countdown or “only 3 left”, ask whether you wanted the thing before you saw it was scarce.
Unity
New in the 2021 edition. In an article announcing it, Cialdini wrote that people are inclined to favour someone who shares a significant social identity, “someone they consider one of them”. Its power, he wrote, comes from shared identities such as family, nationality or religion rather than shared tastes.
What holds up, and where the book overstates
What the sources show for each idea
The broad picture holds: people do take mental shortcuts, and several of the techniques work in controlled tests. But the size of the effects is often smaller than the book’s stories suggest, and one famous story, the 38 silent witnesses, is not supported by the evidence.
The 38 silent witnesses
The book uses the 1964 killing of Catherine (Kitty) Genovese in Queens to explain why a crowd of onlookers can fail to help. The textbook edition quotes the news story’s line that “38 respectable, law-abiding citizens in Queens watched a killer”.
In 2016 the Times itself called the portrayal of 38 fully aware and unresponsive witnesses erroneous. Some neighbours did ignore her cries, but the original article grossly exaggerated how many witnesses there were and what they saw. Afterward two people did call the police.
The broader finding is real but narrower than the story. A 2011 meta-analysis found that each person is less likely to help when others are present, an effect weaker in dangerous emergencies.
Who it’s for, and who can skip it
It suits readers who want a lively, story-led tour of persuasion, and anyone who wants to recognise the tactics used on them in shops, sales calls and fundraising.
Readers who want effect sizes and replication status will need to look past it to the later research. Readers who already know the six principles from courses or summaries will find little new in the core ideas.
Quick answers
What are Cialdini's principles of persuasion?
Reciprocity, commitment and consistency, social proof, liking, authority and scarcity. The 2021 edition adds a seventh, unity.
Does the door-in-the-face technique work?
It moves spoken agreement more than action. A 2025 review of 50 years of studies found both effects significant but small: r = .14 for verbal compliance and r = .08 for behavioural compliance.
Did 38 people really watch Kitty Genovese's murder and do nothing?
The evidence does not support it. A 2007 study of the archive found no evidence that there were 38 witnesses, that they saw the murder, or that they did nothing, and in 2016 the Times called its portrayal erroneous.
Did the Milgram obedience experiment hold up?
The obedience did: a 2006 partial replication, stopped at 150 volts, found obedience only slightly lower than Milgram's. Why people obeyed is still argued over.
Use this
Most of these cues work quietly, so the defence is a pause at the moment of yes.
Would I still say yes if nobody had pushed me to say it now?
Quick quiz
Nothing is scored or saved. Recalling it once now is what makes it last.
1. In Langer's study, how did an empty reason do when the favour was large?
Answer: No better than no reason.Read it again ↑
2. What did a 2007 study of the archive find about the 38 witnesses to Kitty Genovese's murder?
Answer: No evidence there were 38 who saw it and did nothing.Read it again ↑
3. In the 21 versions of Milgram's experiment where obeying meant going to the maximum shock, what share of people did?
Answer: 43.6%.Read it again ↑
How we checked this · Last checked October 2026
- What we read: short search-inside passages of the 1984 and 1993 printings and of the 2009 textbook edition, the author's own pages on his principles and books, and his 2021 article announcing unity, which is how the unity principle is described here.
- For the studies we read the full texts of the 1978 photocopier study, the 1985 replication, the 2016 towel re-analysis and its 2017 reply, and the 2016 New York Times obituary (archived copy); for the others, the abstracts.
- The verdict on the hotel towels is our reading of a dispute between researchers; both sides are on the page.
Sources
- R. B. Cialdini, Influence: How and Why People Agree to Things (William Morrow, 1984) and Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion (William Morrow, 1993), search-inside snippets of the Internet Archive copies (1984, 1993).Primary
- R. B. Cialdini, Influence: Science and Practice, 5th edition (Pearson, 2009), search-inside snippets.Primary
- Influence at Work, “About Dr. Cialdini”, “Principles of persuasion” and the books page (2021 edition).Popular
- R. B. Cialdini, “This should be labeled a universal principle of influence”, Psychology Today, 5 April 2021.Popular
- E. Langer, A. Blank and B. Chanowitz, “The mindlessness of ostensibly thoughtful action”, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 36 (1978).Scholarly
- V. S. Folkes, “Mindlessness or mindfulness: a partial replication and extension”, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 48 (1985).Scholarly
- M. S. Key, J. E. Edlund, B. J. Sagarin and G. Y. Bizer, “Individual differences in susceptibility to mindlessness”, Personality and Individual Differences 46 (2009).Scholarly
- R. B. Cialdini et al., “Reciprocal concessions procedure for inducing compliance: the door-in-the-face technique”, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 31 (1975).Scholarly
- T. H. Feeley, A. E. Anker and A. M. Aloe, “The door-in-the-face persuasive message strategy: a meta-analysis of the first 35 years”, Communication Monographs 79 (2012).Scholarly
- O. Genschow et al., “Does social psychology persist over half a century? A direct replication of Cialdini et al.’s (1975) classic door-in-the-face technique”, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 120 (2021).Scholarly
- T. H. Feeley, “50-year review of the door-in-the-face message strategy”, Communication Monographs (online 16 December 2025).Scholarly
- J. M. Burger, “The foot-in-the-door compliance procedure: a multiple-process analysis and review”, Personality and Social Psychology Review 3 (1999).Scholarly
- M. Gamian-Wilk and D. Dolinski, “The foot-in-the-door phenomenon 40 and 50 years later”, Psychological Reports 123 (2020).Scholarly
- J. M. Burger and D. Caputo, “The low-ball compliance procedure: a meta-analysis”, Social Influence 10 (2015).Scholarly
- N. J. Goldstein, R. B. Cialdini and V. Griskevicius, “A room with a viewpoint”, Journal of Consumer Research 35 (2008).Scholarly
- G. Bohner and L. E. Schlüter, “A room with a viewpoint revisited”, PLoS ONE 9 (2014).Scholarly
- G. Reese, K. Loew and G. Steffgen, “A towel less: social norms enhance pro-environmental behavior in hotels”, Journal of Social Psychology 154 (2014).Scholarly
- B. Scheibehenne, T. Jamil and E.-J. Wagenmakers, “Bayesian evidence synthesis can reconcile seemingly inconsistent results”, Psychological Science 27 (2016).Scholarly
- B. Scheibehenne, Q. F. Gronau, T. Jamil and E.-J. Wagenmakers, “Fixed or random? A resolution through model averaging”, Psychological Science 28 (2017).Scholarly
- J. M. Burger et al., “What a coincidence! The effects of incidental similarity on compliance”, Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 30 (2004).Scholarly
- S. Milgram, “Behavioral study of obedience”, Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology 67 (1963).Scholarly
- J. M. Burger, “Replicating Milgram: would people still obey today?”, American Psychologist 64 (2009).Scholarly
- S. A. Haslam, S. D. Reicher, K. Millard and R. McDonald, “‘Happy to have been of service’”, British Journal of Social Psychology 54 (2015).Scholarly
- G. Perry, A. Brannigan, R. A. Wanner and H. Stam, “Credibility and incredulity in Milgram’s obedience experiments”, Social Psychology Quarterly 83 (2020).Scholarly
- N. Haslam, S. Loughnan and G. Perry, “Meta-Milgram: an empirical synthesis of the obedience experiments”, PLoS ONE 9 (2014).Scholarly
- S. Worchel, J. Lee and A. Adewole, “Effects of supply and demand on ratings of object value”, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 32 (1975).Scholarly
- B. Barton, N. Zlatevska and H. Oppewal, “Scarcity tactics in marketing: a meta-analysis of product scarcity effects on consumer purchase intentions”, Journal of Retailing 98 (2022).Scholarly
- R. Manning, M. Levine and A. Collins, “The Kitty Genovese murder and the social psychology of helping”, American Psychologist 62 (2007).Scholarly
- R. D. McFadden, “Winston Moseley, 81, killer of Kitty Genovese, dies in prison”, The New York Times, 4 April 2016 (archived).Popular
- P. Fischer et al., “The bystander-effect: a meta-analytic review”, Psychological Bulletin 137 (2011).Scholarly