Start hereThe book says only 7 percent of a message is in the words. The researcher behind that figure says it does not apply unless people are talking about their feelings or attitudes. So which of the book's techniques hold up?
About the book
Never Split the Difference: Negotiating As If Your Life Depended On It is by Chris Voss, written with Tahl Raz. Harper Business published it in May 2016; the library catalogue record gives viii, 274 pages.
It is a practical guide for a general reader. Each chapter teaches one principle through a story, often from a hostage or kidnapping case. The book’s stories include a kidnapping in Haiti and one in the Philippines. Then it applies the principle to everyday deals: the catalogue description lists buying a car, negotiating a salary, buying a home and renegotiating rent.
Who Chris Voss is
The publisher’s description says Voss worked as a hostage negotiator and rose to become the FBI’s lead international kidnapping negotiator. Outside the book, NBC News reported in 2009 that Voss had been the FBI’s lead international kidnapping negotiator from 2003 to 2007. He retired in 2007 after 24 years in the FBI.
People negotiate with feelings first
The book opens at Harvard. Robert Mnookin, director of the Harvard Negotiation Research Project, asked Voss over just to chat and drew him into an impromptu negotiation. Voss answered each move with some version of “How am I supposed to do that?”.
He then contrasts his approach with Getting to Yes, which he calls a groundbreaking treatise on negotiation. That book rests on the idea that the two sides can reason their way to a deal that suits both. In his experience, “Getting to Yes didn’t work with kidnappers”. His claim is that a negotiation is mostly about the other side’s emotions and fears, and only then about logic.
Tactical empathy
His central tool he calls tactical empathy: understanding the feelings and mindset of the other person, and using that understanding to influence what happens next. He describes it as “listening as a martial art”.
Mirror, then label
Two listening moves do most of the work. A mirror, in FBI practice as the book describes it, is repeating the last three words, or the critical one to three words, of what someone just said. It invites them to say more. A label names the feeling you hear. In the book’s words, “Labeling is a way of validating someone’s emotion by acknowledging it.”
Does naming someone’s feelings calm them down?
Related research supports part of it. FBI crisis-negotiation training lists emotional labelling as a core skill and says it tends to defuse emotion. But the studies it reports are role-play training studies, not tests in real incidents.
- Lab studies of affect labelling found that putting feelings into words damped the reaction of the person doing the labelling. A 2007 brain-imaging study found less amygdala response to negative images.
- The closest test of naming someone else’s feelings is a 2021 study of 74 couples. A label chosen by the partner reduced distress more than people labelling their own feelings. It worked better the more empathic the partner.
- A 2026 replication also found that labelling made a later calming strategy, reappraisal, work less well, and that ratings had returned to baseline a day or two later.
We found no such study of negotiators.
Does mirroring build rapport?
Sometimes, and it backfires when people notice it.
- In two experiments in a law office, published in 2023, clients more often gave legal representation to a lawyer who mimicked them verbally. The authors note the samples were small.
- A preregistered 2016 study in which avatars mimicked people’s head and torso movements found no effect on rapport or trust.
- A 2023 study found subtle mimicry raised liking, while strong mimicry lowered liking and trust, and noticing it backfired.
- A 2026 meta-analysis of 26 comparisons in lab studies of movement mimicry found a positive effect on liking, smaller when the comparison partner moved naturally rather than keeping still.
Try it: offer a label as a guess (“You seem frustrated”). FBI training notes that even a wrong guess shows you are trying to understand. Mirror now and then, not after every sentence.
Look for “no”, not “yes”
Voss warns that pushing for a yes tends to get you a counterfeit one. Saying no, he writes, makes the speaker “feel safe, secure, and in control”. “‘No’ is the start of the negotiation, not the end of it,” he writes.
Has anyone tested no-oriented questions?
We found no study that tests them. The nearest research is on telling people they are free to refuse. A meta-analysis of 42 studies found that it raised compliance in most contexts. That is a related idea, not a test of the book’s technique.
Try it: a simpler habit from that research: when you ask for something, make it clear the other person is free to say no.
Ask “how” and “what”
Instead of arguing, he asks open questions that begin with how or what, which he calls calibrated questions. He says they make the other side feel in charge. He ranks the question from the Harvard scene among the “greatest-of-all-time” calibrated questions.
Bend their reality, then bargain hard
On money, the book’s advice is to let the other side go first most of the time. But when you do name numbers, it says, set an extreme anchor so that your real offer seems reasonable.
For haggling it offers the Ackerman model, named after Mike Ackerman, whom the book describes as “an ex-CIA type” who founded a kidnap-for-ransom consulting company. The steps, as the book sets them out:
- Set a target price.
- Open at 65 percent of it.
- Raise in decreasing steps to 85, 95 and 100 percent.
- Use precise, nonround numbers at the end, and on the final number throw in a nonmonetary item.
Do extreme anchors work?
Anchors work; extreme ones carry a risk. In experiments, whichever side made the first offer tended to get the better outcome, and the effect held across cultures and issues. Our cognitive biases page rates anchoring, tested there with numbers given in a question, as having held up.
But in 26 million eBay negotiations, lower buyer offers pulled prices down, while an overly ambitious offer raised the risk of no deal at all. A 2026 review says too assertive an offer can alienate the other side.
Does the Ackerman model work?
We found no study of the full sequence. On its parts, a 2016 study found that more precise opening numbers anchored amateurs more, but that experts saw too much precision as a lack of competence. On the opening, the eBay study found that very low buyer offers raise the risk of impasse.
Find the black swans
The last chapter is about unknown unknowns; the publisher’s page sums it up as revealing the unknown unknowns. In the book, Black Swans are events or pieces of knowledge outside what we expect, and Voss calls them leverage multipliers. His advice is to dig for them by listening, and, where possible, by getting face time with the other side.
What holds up, and what the book overstates
What the sources show for each idea
The book’s listening tools come from FBI crisis negotiation training, which is well documented. The FBI’s own model, the Behavioral Change Stairway Model, was developed by its Crisis Negotiation Unit. A 2005 review co-written by a member of that unit lists mirroring and emotional labelling among the core skills. The studies that review reports are role-play training studies. Expert negotiators used more active-listening skills than non-experts, and training increased them; it reports no controlled study of real incidents.
Beyond that, the research is a mix. First offers do anchor deals, and the listening tools have indirect support. Two of the book’s claims do not hold up as stated, and one piece of advice is still argued.
Is only 7 percent of a message the words?
Not as a general rule. The 7-38-55 split comes from Albert Mehrabian’s 1967 experiments on inconsistent messages about feelings and attitudes. Mehrabian’s own page says the equations do not apply “unless a communicator is talking about their feelings or attitudes”. The book uses the rule to argue for paying close attention to tone, which is closer to what was studied.
Try it: when someone says “fine” in a flat voice, the mismatch is worth a follow-up question.
Do liars use more words?
Not as a general rule. In the 2012 ultimatum-game study the book cites, liars generally used more words, although truthful players with suspicious partners did not differ from liars on word count.
A 2015 meta-analysis of computer-coded language cues found the opposite on average: across 42 studies, liars used fewer words than truth-tellers, a small effect that varied widely between studies. A 2003 meta-analysis found liars “less forthcoming” and that many behaviours showed no link, or only weak links, to lying.
Moving first or second: a genuine disagreement
The case for moving first. In three experiments published in 2001, whichever party, buyer or seller, made the first offer obtained a better outcome. Later work found the effect remarkably robust across cultures and in negotiations over several issues. The same 2001 paper found the advantage disappeared when the side receiving the offer thought about the first mover’s alternatives or limit, or about its own target.
The case for moving second. The book’s advice is to let the other side go first “most of the time”. One argument for it is that the other side’s number tells you something. A 2017 study tested that with written scenarios and a classroom negotiation exercise. When one side had full background information and the other had none, it was better for both sides, the informed one included, not to make the first offer. A 2021 paper names the gap between practitioners’ advice to move second and researchers’ advice to move first the “Practitioner-Researcher paradox”.
Where it leans. Information explains much of the gap. According to the 2017 paper, the existing research deals almost solely with cases where both sides have a clear reference for the market price. It suggests moving first is best there. Where one side knew far more than the other, its studies favoured waiting, for the informed side too. That rests on one paper, mostly using written scenarios, so it is a lead rather than a settled rule.
Our reading: moving first is well supported when both sides know the market. When one side knows much more than the other, the one study we found favours waiting, and that case is still open. The book’s advice is stronger than the evidence supports.
Who it’s for, and who can skip it
It suits readers who negotiate often, or who dread it, and want concrete phrases to try. The stories are vivid and the listening tools are easy to practise.
Readers who want evidence for each technique will find the book stronger on stories than on studies. People who already know Getting to Yes or crisis-negotiation training will recognise much of the listening material, here told through case stories.
Quick answers
Was Chris Voss really an FBI hostage negotiator?
NBC News reported in 2009 that he was the FBI's lead international kidnapping negotiator from 2003 to 2007. He retired in 2007 after 24 years in the FBI.
Does mirroring work in negotiation?
Sometimes. Subtle mimicry raised liking in some studies, a preregistered study found no effect on rapport, and strong mimicry lowered liking and trust.
Should you make the first offer?
Researchers and practitioners disagree. Our reading: moving first is well supported when both sides know the market; when one side knows much more, the one study we found favours waiting.
Is the 7-38-55 rule true?
Not as a general rule. Mehrabian's own page says the equations do not apply unless someone is talking about their feelings or attitudes.
What is the Ackerman model?
A haggling sequence from the book: open at 65 percent of your target, raise in decreasing steps to 85, 95 and 100 percent, and end on precise numbers. We found no study of the full sequence.
Use this
Use the listening tools lightly, and treat the number rules with care.
Am I listening to understand, or waiting to make my point?
Quick quiz
Nothing is scored or saved. Recalling it once now is what makes it last.
1. Where does the "7 percent words" rule come from?
Answer: Studies of messages about feelings and attitudes.Read it again ↑
2. What did a 2015 meta-analysis of 42 studies find about liars and word count?
Answer: Liars used fewer words, on average.Read it again ↑
3. In the Ackerman model, where does the opening offer sit?
Answer: 65 percent of your target.Read it again ↑
How we checked this · Last checked October 2026
- The book's wording comes from the catalogue record, the publisher's description and short passages found through the Open Library search-inside tool.
- Voss's FBI role comes from a 2009 NBC News report. We did not check each case story in the book against outside records.
- For the research we read the abstracts, plus the full texts of the 2005 FBI review, the 2023 law-office study, the 2017 information study and the 2015 meta-analysis of language cues to lying.
- In October 2026 we searched again and still found no study of no-oriented questions or of the Ackerman model as a whole.
Sources
- C. Voss with T. Raz, Never Split the Difference: Negotiating As If Your Life Depended On It (Harper Business, 2016): catalogue record and short passages via the Open Library search-inside tool; publisher’s page.Primary
- E. Angulo, “How do you negotiate with a pirate? Be patient”, NBC News (14 April 2009).Popular
- G. M. Vecchi, V. B. Van Hasselt and S. J. Romano, “Crisis (hostage) negotiation: current strategies and issues in high-risk conflict resolution”, Aggression and Violent Behavior 10 (2005).Scholarly
- M. D. Lieberman et al., “Putting feelings into words”, Psychological Science 18 (2007).Scholarly
- J. B. Torre and M. D. Lieberman, “Putting feelings into words: affect labeling as implicit emotion regulation”, Emotion Review (2018).Scholarly
- Y. Ariely et al., “Affect labeling and reappraisal as an emotion regulation strategy”, Affective Science 7 (2026).Scholarly
- S. G. Shamay-Tsoory and E. Levy-Gigi, “You name it: interpersonal affect labeling diminishes distress in romantic couples”, Behavior Therapy 52 (2021).Scholarly
- W. Kulesza et al., “Mimicry and law”, PLOS ONE (2023).Scholarly
- R. Hale and A. F. de C. Hamilton, “Testing the relationship between mimicry, trust and rapport in virtual reality conversations”, Scientific Reports 6 (2016).Scholarly
- M. H. Wessler, D. D. Loschelder, J. C. Fendel and M. Friese, “The too-much-mimicry effect”, Journal of Nonverbal Behavior (2023).Scholarly
- W. D. Trzmielewska and T. Rak, “Confederate motor behavior in control conditions and liking effects of being mimicked”, Journal of Nonverbal Behavior (2026).Scholarly
- A. Mehrabian, “Silent Messages”, author’s website (Internet Archive copy); A. Mehrabian and M. Wiener, “Decoding of inconsistent communications”, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 6 (1967); A. Mehrabian and S. R. Ferris, “Inference of attitudes from nonverbal communication in two channels”, Journal of Consulting Psychology 31 (1967).Scholarly
- C. J. Carpenter, “A meta-analysis of the effectiveness of the ‘but you are free’ compliance-gaining technique”, Communication Studies 64 (2013).Scholarly
- A. D. Galinsky and T. Mussweiler, “First offers as anchors”, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 81 (2001).Scholarly
- B. C. Gunia et al., “The remarkable robustness of the first-offer effect”, Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 39 (2013).Scholarly
- Y. Maaravi and A. Levy, “When your anchor sinks your boat”, Judgment and Decision Making 12 (2017).Scholarly
- Y. Maaravi and B. Heller, “Buyers, maybe moving second is not that bad after all”, Frontiers in Psychology 12 (2021).Scholarly
- M. Schweinsberg, H. M. Petrowsky, B. Funk and D. D. Loschelder, “Understanding the first-offer conundrum”, PNAS 120 (2023).Scholarly
- D. D. Loschelder and H. M. Petrowsky, “The influential first offer: how to advance a negotiation classic by integrating features, mechanisms, and outcomes”, Current Opinion in Psychology (2026).Scholarly
- D. D. Loschelder, M. Friese, M. Schaerer and A. D. Galinsky, “The too-much-precision effect”, Psychological Science 27 (2016).Scholarly
- L. M. Van Swol, M. T. Braun and D. Malhotra, “Evidence for the Pinocchio effect”, Discourse Processes (2012).Scholarly
- B. M. DePaulo et al., “Cues to deception”, Psychological Bulletin 129 (2003).Scholarly
- V. Hauch et al., “Are computers effective lie detectors?”, Personality and Social Psychology Review (2015).Scholarly