Skip to content

Mindset

17 min left
CHECKED · INFORMATION AND ATTENTION

Information Is Power: Who to Listen To, and How to Choose What You Feed Your Mind

Who to listen to, four questions to ask before believing, and where "knowledge is power" began.

Hacks Vitae artwork (AI-assisted)
The answer

Our reading: give most weight to sources that lose something when they are wrong, or have a track record you can check.

Before believing a claim, ask who gains, whether it is fact or opinion, where it first appeared, and whether others agree. Even "knowledge is power" has a catch: Bacon's 1597 line was an aside about God; Hobbes added "but a small one".

Why it mattersClaims you meet again and again feel truer, even false ones, so choosing what you take in matters.

Our verdicts
  • 3Doesn't hold up
  • 4Partly
  • 2Holds up
  • 1Still argued

See every verdict →

By Hacks Vitae Published Updated Last checked October 2026 17 min read 35 sources ↓

Start here"Knowledge is power" gets quoted as a promise. Yet the exact Latin, Thomas Hobbes's of 1668, goes on "but a small one". So which information is worth taking in, and from whom?

“Knowledge is power” is a familiar line. Where it comes from turns out to be a good place to start, because it says something useful about how information turns into power, and how often it does not.

This page rests on one idea, and it is our own way of putting it: your mind works a little like your stomach. What you take in, again and again, shapes how you think. That is a comparison, not a scientific finding, and the page says where research bears on it and where it does not.

The verdicts

01 "Knowledge is power" is Francis Bacon's lineCredited to Francis Bacon Partly His Latin words of 1597, but an aside about God's knowledge being part of God's power. Evidence ↓
02 Scientia potentia est is Bacon's LatinCredited to Francis Bacon Doesn't hold up That exact form is Thomas Hobbes's, from 1668, and he added "but a small one". Evidence ↓
03 "A wealth of information creates a poverty of attention" is Herbert Simon'sCredited to Herbert Simon Holds up It is in his 1971 essay, as quoted in Oxford Essential Quotations. Evidence ↓
04 The average attention span is now shorter than a goldfish'sCredited to Popular claim Doesn't hold up The BBC traced the figure in 2017; its sources could find no research behind it. Evidence ↓
05 Hearing something again makes it seem truerCredited to Popular claim Holds up Studied since 1977, even when people knew the answer; how long it lasts is unsettled. Evidence ↓
06 False news spreads faster than true newsCredited to Popular claim Partly A 2018 Twitter study found it; a 2021 reanalysis traced the difference to larger cascades. Evidence ↓
07 Echo chambers and filter bubbles trap most peopleCredited to Popular claim Still argued A 2022 review found them rarer than assumed; 2023 Facebook studies found mostly like-minded content. Evidence ↓
08 Following the news makes people anxiousCredited to Popular claim Partly Small experiments show short-term rises; longer-term links come from surveys that cannot show cause. Evidence ↓
09 Nassim Taleb coined "skin in the game"Credited to Nassim Taleb Doesn't hold up The Oxford English Dictionary dates the phrase from 1976, decades before his 2018 book. Evidence ↓
10 Munger's "Psychology of Human Misjudgment" was a single 1995 talkCredited to Charlie Munger Partly He gave one in April 1995; the published text combines talks of 1992, 1994 and 1995. Evidence ↓
6 of 10 shown · a mix of every verdict

A quick filter before you believe something

Here are four questions. None of them takes long, and the last two link to pages that go deeper.

  1. Who is saying it, and what do they gain? Gain is not only money: attention, followers and status count too. A motive tells you how much to lean on someone’s word. It does not settle whether their argument holds.

  2. Is it a fact, an opinion or a feeling? A Pew Research Center survey of 5,035 US adults in 2018 defined a factual statement as one that objective evidence can prove or disprove. An opinion, it said, reflects the beliefs and values of whoever expressed it.

    A majority correctly sorted at least three of five statements of each kind. Pew called that result only a little better than random guesses.

    The third category, a feeling, is our addition. A statement can describe how someone feels about a thing and still be presented as a fact about it.

  3. Where is the original source? A quote, a statistic or a study is only as good as the place it first appeared. Our guides on finding where a quote first appeared, on numbers that mislead and on reading a study cover the three cases.

  4. Do other trustworthy sources agree? One quick way to find out is to leave the page and see what others say about the source and the claim. That is lateral reading, the core of the SIFT method.

    The same questions apply when the answer comes from an AI chatbot. Our page on critical thinking in the age of AI looks at what studies have found.

Who to listen to

Two signals help here, in our reading: what a source loses when it is wrong, and what it gains from your attention.

People who pay a price when they are wrong

Nassim Nicholas Taleb’s book Skin in the Game, published by Random House in 2018, is built around this. The publisher’s description quotes him: “Never trust anyone who doesn’t have skin in the game”. Without it, he says, fools and crooks benefit, and their mistakes never catch up with them.

The publisher’s description puts the rule in plain words: you cannot make profits and pass the risks on to others. Our summary of Skin in the Game covers what holds up.

Our reading: someone who loses something when they are wrong has a reason to be careful. That loss might be money, reputation or their own health.

Someone with a track record you can check has given you something to check. Neither is proof that they are right, but both are better signals than confidence.

People who are paid by your attention

If a source earns from your attention, its first job is to hold that attention. Being right does not always do that.

Charlie Munger, in his talk on human misjudgment, put incentives first on his list. He thought he had been in the top 5 percent of his age group in understanding the power of incentives for almost all his adult life. Yet he had always underestimated that power, he said.

This is not a reason to dismiss anyone. In “How to Disagree”, Paul Graham gives the example of a senator arguing that senators’ pay should rise: “Of course he would say that. He’s a senator.”

That reply, he writes, would not refute the argument, but it may at least be relevant to the case. Our logical fallacies cheat sheet draws the same line: facts about a person matter when you are relying on their word, not when you are judging their reasoning.

Watch your own bias, and find the strongest version of the other side

The filter above points outwards. The harder part points inwards, because the same shortcuts work on whoever is doing the checking. Our cognitive biases page checks fourteen of the famous findings and which held up.

Munger made a practical point about one of these shortcuts. People hold on to the first conclusion they reach. So, he noted, judges and juries must sit through long, skilful presentations of the side they would not naturally favour. He said this helps prevent a good deal of bad thinking caused by first-conclusion bias.

John Stuart Mill made the same argument in On Liberty, published in 1859: “He who knows only his own side of the case, knows little of that”. It is not enough, he wrote, to hear the other side from your own teachers. You need to meet its arguments at their most plausible and persuasive.

Today this is sometimes called steelmanning, the opposite of a straw man. In the OpenStax textbook Introduction to Philosophy, to steelman an argument is to make the strongest possible case in favour of it.

Paul Graham’s essay “How to Disagree”, from March 2008, gives a ladder for judging the replies themselves. It runs from DH0 to DH6: name-calling, ad hominem, responding to tone, contradiction, counterargument, refutation, and refuting the central point.

The levels, he notes, describe the form of a reply, not whether it is correct. A DH6 reply might still be unconvincing, but one at DH2 or lower is always unconvincing.

Graham’s essay does not use the word steelman. In our reading, the two ideas fit together: you cannot refute someone’s central point until you have stated it in a form they would accept.

Fewer, deeper sources

Seneca’s second letter is the classic case for depth. “Everywhere means nowhere,” in Gummere’s translation (2.2).

A person who spends all their time travelling, he says, ends up with many acquaintances but no friends. The same holds for readers who visit every author in a hasty, hurried way.

His advice in Latin is short: probatos itaque semper lege. In our translation: so always read the tried and tested ones. Our summary of Letters from a Stoic covers the rest of the letters.

Bacon’s essay “Of Studies” adds a rule for how to read, not just how much. Read, he says, not to argue against, not to believe and take for granted, and not to find things to talk about, “but to weigh and consider”.

His sorting of books into tasted, swallowed, and chewed and digested is a way to spend attention unevenly on purpose. A few books, he says, are to be read wholly, with diligence and attention.

Depth does not mean narrowness. Our page on the Renaissance man looks at what research says about range and depth together.

Partly

Where “knowledge is power” comes from

Credited to Francis Bacon

Bacon’s line was about God

The Latin words begin with Francis Bacon, in a passage about God. In February 1597 Bacon published the first edition of his Essayes. The same volume held his Religious Meditations and Places of Perswasion and Disswasion.

The meditations, the Meditationes Sacrae, are in Latin. One of them is titled De Haeresibus, “Of Heresies”.

In it, Bacon criticises people who give God’s knowledge a wider range than God’s power. He then puts it more exactly: a wider range to the part of God’s power by which God knows than to the part by which he works and acts.

In brackets he adds the famous phrase: “for knowledge itself is power”. That is the English of James Spedding’s 1859 edition. The Latin of the aside reads nam et ipsa scientia potestas est.

In context, the knowledge is God’s, and Bacon’s point is that God’s knowing is part of God’s power. It is not advice about getting ahead.

Bacon’s human version came later

Bacon did write about human knowledge and power, more than twenty years later. In the Novum Organum, published in October 1620, the third aphorism reads Scientia et potentia humana in idem coincidunt. In our translation: human knowledge and human power come to the same thing.

Joseph Devey’s translation begins “Knowledge and human power are synonymous”. The reason it gives: if you do not know the cause, you cannot bring about the effect, and nature is mastered only by submitting to it.

The exact Latin is Hobbes’s, and he added a catch

The tidy Latin form, scientia potentia est, is Thomas Hobbes’s. Around 1620 Hobbes worked for a time as a secretary to Bacon.

In the Latin edition of Leviathan, published in 1668, Hobbes writes Scientia potentia est; sed parva. In our translation: knowledge is power, but a small one. It is small, he says, because outstanding knowledge is rare and is seen by very few (our translation of quia scientia egregia rara est).

His English Leviathan of 1651 makes the same point: “The Sciences, are small Power; because not eminent; and therefore, not acknowledged in any man”.

The idea itself is older than either man. The King James Version of Proverbs 24:5 reads: “A wise man is strong; yea, a man of knowledge increaseth strength”.

Our reading: the line is less a promise than a pair of conditions. Bacon’s version needs knowledge of causes that you can act on. Hobbes’s caveat is that knowledge only counts as power when other people can see it.

↑ All verdicts

Your mind is like your stomach (our framing)

This section offers a comparison, not a claim that the brain digests information the way the body digests food. What you read, watch and scroll through, again and again, becomes the material you think with.

The comparison is old. Seneca makes it in his second letter to Lucilius. Food does no good, he writes, and is not taken into the body if it leaves the stomach as soon as it is eaten. Toying with many dishes, he adds, is the sign of an over-fussy appetite (Letter 2.3–2.4, in Richard M. Gummere’s translation).

Francis Bacon used the same image in his essay “Of Studies”: “Some books are to be tasted, others to be swallowed, and some few to be chewed and digested”. The line was already in the first edition of 1597.

Modern writers have kept the comparison going. Clay Johnson’s book The Information Diet is summed up in its catalogue record the same way. Too much junk information can lead to cluelessness, just as too much junk food can lead to obesity.

Rolf Dobelli’s 2013 essay in The Guardian argued that “news is to the mind what sugar is to the body”. Both are arguments by their authors, not research findings.

Where research bears on it: repetition

One finding fits the comparison closely. The illusory truth effect is the finding that people rate statements as truer when they have seen them before.

The first paper on it was published in 1977, by Lynn Hasher, David Goldstein and Thomas Toppino. A 2010 meta-analysis pooled 51 studies of it.

Two later results matter for everyday reading.

The effect holds up, with limits.

The 2021 study’s authors point out a conflict. Their finding that the effect fades does not fit an earlier meta-analysis, which found no link across studies between the size of the effect and the delay between sessions.

In short: repetition makes claims feel truer, reliably in the lab. How long the effect lasts is not settled.

Where research bears on it: attention

The economist and computer scientist Herbert Simon put the other half of the problem in a 1971 essay, “Designing Organizations for an Information-Rich World”. In an information-rich world, he wrote, the wealth of information means a shortage of something else: the attention of those who receive it. “Hence a wealth of information creates a poverty of attention”.

If attention is the scarce thing, then choosing what to feed your mind is also choosing where your attention goes.

Our attention span is now shorter than a goldfish’s

Doesn't hold up The comparison is vivid and the numbers sound precise, but no research has been found behind them. The claim says the average attention span fell from 12 seconds in 2000 to 8, less than a goldfish’s 9.

The BBC statistics programme More or Less traced it in 2017. The figure led back to a 2015 industry report, which credited it to another website. The sources that website listed could find no research behind it.

One attention researcher told the BBC that attention depends very much on the task. The programme concluded there was no evidence that human attention spans are shrinking.

A different, narrower measure has changed. Gloria Mark studies how long office workers stay on one screen before switching. She told the American Psychological Association in 2023 that the average fell from about two and a half minutes in 2004 to about 47 seconds in recent years.

That is time on one screen at work, not a general attention span, and it is not the 8-second figure. Goldfish do not have short memories either, as our real or myth page explains.

False news spreads faster than true news

Partly A widely cited study is behind this one, though a later reanalysis explains its result differently. Published in Science in 2018, it looked at about 126,000 stories on Twitter from 2006 to 2017. Six fact-checking organisations had judged each one true or false. Falsehood, it found, spread “farther, faster, deeper, and more broadly than the truth”.

The study also found that bots spread true and false stories at the same rate. The authors took this to mean that people, not bots, did the extra spreading.

A 2021 reanalysis in PNAS compared stories that spread to the same size. It found that the reported differences in how they spread can almost entirely be explained by the false-news cascades being larger.

So false stories reached more people in that data. Whether they travel by a different mechanism is less clear. Both studies are about Twitter, and about stories fact-checkers had checked.

Echo chambers and filter bubbles trap most people

Still argued Researchers disagree here, and the studies point in different directions.

A 2022 literature review by the Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism found echo chambers much less widespread than is commonly assumed. It found no support for the filter bubble hypothesis. Studies in the UK put the share of people in politically partisan online news echo chambers at between six and eight percent.

On the other side, a 2023 study in Nature used data from 2020 for all active adult Facebook users in the US. Content from like-minded sources made up the majority of what people saw, although political information and news were only a small fraction of it.

In the same study, cutting that content by about one-third for 23,377 users had no measurable effect on eight measures of attitudes.

A companion 2023 study in Science used aggregated data for 208 million US Facebook users. It found that ideological segregation in political news is high. It also grows as you move from what people could see, to what they did see, to what they engaged with.

Our reading: one-sided feeds are common on some platforms, but being fully sealed off is rare. The effect of one-sided exposure on beliefs is small or unproven in the studies so far. Both Facebook studies covered US users during the 2020 election.

Following the news makes people anxious

Partly The short-term part has support, which makes the larger claim easy to believe. Small experiments show that watching negative news can raise anxiety in the short term.

Longer-term effects rest on surveys. After the Boston Marathon bombings, a 2014 study in PNAS looked at people’s media exposure in the week after. Six or more hours a day of bombing-related media exposure was associated with more acute stress than direct exposure to the bombings.

A 2023 study of US adults described what it called “problematic news consumption”. It found greater mental and physical ill-being among the 16.5% with the most severe pattern. A 2025 replication over two waves found 7.5% in that group, and the link with physical ill-being did not hold over time.

Surveys like these show links. They cannot settle whether news causes lasting distress, or distressed people follow more news.

Taleb coined “skin in the game”

Doesn't hold up The phrase is the title of his book, which explains the link, but it is older than the book. The Oxford English Dictionary dates the phrase from 1976, decades before Taleb’s 2018 book. It labels the phrase colloquial, first used in North American business.

What Taleb did was turn a business phrase into a broad rule about risk and fairness.

Munger’s misjudgment talk was a single 1995 talk

Partly He gave a talk on the subject on 24 April 1995. But the published text combines three talks, from 1992, 1994 and 1995, revised by Munger in 2005.

Munger’s book Poor Charlie’s Almanack describes it as selections from three of his talks, combined into one talk never given. The book’s note on the talk calls it a checklist of 25 standard causes of human misjudgment.

Further reading

These books take up the same theme, and each has a summary on this site:

Three more on the same ground:

  • Verified by Mike Caulfield and Sam Wineburg (2023), a guide that builds on techniques such as SIFT and lateral reading.
  • Stop Reading the News by Rolf Dobelli (2020).
  • The Filter Bubble by Eli Pariser (2011).

Quick answers

Who said "knowledge is power"?

Francis Bacon wrote the Latin in 1597, as a bracketed aside in a passage about God's knowledge and power; James Spedding's 1859 edition gives it as "for knowledge itself is power". The exact form scientia potentia est is Thomas Hobbes's, from 1668, and it goes on sed parva: in our translation, but a small one.

Is our attention span shorter than a goldfish's?

No research has been found behind that claim. When the BBC's More or Less traced the 8-second figure in 2017, its sources could find no research behind it, and the programme concluded there was no evidence that attention spans are shrinking.

What is steelmanning?

To steelman an argument is to make the strongest possible case in favour of it, the opposite of a straw man. John Stuart Mill made the same argument in 1859: "He who knows only his own side of the case, knows little of that".

Does false news spread faster than true news?

A 2018 study of about 126,000 Twitter stories found falsehood spread farther and faster. A 2021 reanalysis found the differences can almost entirely be explained by the false-news cascades being larger.

Do echo chambers trap most people?

Researchers disagree. A 2022 Reuters Institute review found echo chambers much less widespread than commonly assumed. A 2023 study of US Facebook users found most of what people saw came from like-minded sources, but cutting that content by about a third had no measurable effect on attitudes.

Use this

The lesson

Take in fewer sources, and check a claim before you believe or share it.

The rule

Who gains if I believe this, and where did it first appear?

Quick quiz

Three questions, thirty seconds

Nothing is scored or saved. Recalling it once now is what makes it last.

1. In Bacon's 1597 text, what was "knowledge itself is power" about?

Answer: God's knowledge being part of God's power.Read it again ↑

2. What does the illusory truth effect describe?

Answer: People rate statements as truer when they have seen them before.Read it again ↑

3. In Pew's 2018 survey, how well did US adults sort facts from opinions?

Answer: Only a little better than random guesses.Read it again ↑

How we checked this · Last checked October 2026
  • We read Bacon, Hobbes, Seneca and Mill in the editions and translations in the Sources; where the English is ours, the page says "our translation".
  • For the studies we read each abstract and, where it was open, the full text.
  • The books under Further reading were not read for this page; their dates come from their publishers' pages and Open Library records. Simon's 1971 essay is quoted through Oxford Essential Quotations.
  • Bacon's "Of Studies" is quoted from a modern-spelling version of the final edition of 1625, The Essays or Counsels, Civil and Moral.
  • Munger's talk was read on the Stripe Press page for Poor Charlie's Almanack.

How we check every article →

Sources

Primary written at the time, by a witness, or the original text Scholarly edited or peer-reviewed work Popular press, blogs and general websites

Knowledge is power

Food for the mind

  • Seneca, Moral Letters to Lucilius, Letter 2, translated by Richard M. Gummere (Wikisource); Latin text (The Latin Library).Primary
  • Clay Johnson, The Information Diet, Open Library record.Popular
  • Rolf Dobelli, “News is bad for you – and giving up reading it will make you happier”, The Guardian, 12 April 2013.Popular
  • Hasher, Goldstein & Toppino, “Frequency and the conference of referential validity”, Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior 16 (1977), doi:10.1016/S0022-5371(77)80012-1.Scholarly
  • Dechêne, Stahl, Hansen & Wänke, “The truth about the truth: a meta-analytic review of the truth effect”, Personality and Social Psychology Review 14 (2010), doi:10.1177/1088868309352251.Scholarly
  • Fazio, Brashier, Payne & Marsh, “Knowledge does not protect against illusory truth”, Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 144 (2015), doi:10.1037/xge0000098.Scholarly
  • Pennycook, Cannon & Rand, “Prior exposure increases perceived accuracy of fake news”, Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 147 (2018), doi:10.1037/xge0000465.Scholarly
  • Henderson, Simons & Barr, “The Trajectory of Truth”, Journal of Cognition 4 (2021), doi:10.5334/joc.161.Scholarly
  • Henderson, Westwood & Simons, “A reproducible systematic map of research on the illusory truth effect”, Psychonomic Bulletin & Review 29 (2022), doi:10.3758/s13423-021-01995-w.Scholarly
  • Herbert A. Simon, “Designing Organizations for an Information-Rich World”, in Martin Greenberger (ed.), Computers, Communications, and the Public Interest (1971), pp. 40–41, as quoted in Oxford Essential Quotations.Primary

Who to listen to, and how to disagree

Popular claims

Reading

Put it to work
Our take

Collect what you can act on

In Bacon's human version, knowledge is power when it shows you causes you can act on. Hobbes called it a small power, because outstanding knowledge is rare and few people see it. Our view: choose information you can use, and let your work show what you know.

Goes with: Where “knowledge is power” comes from ↑

Steps

Plan a month of better inputs

  1. List what you take in. Write down every feed, channel and newsletter you check on a normal day.
  2. Drop one repeater. Cut one source that mostly repeats what you've already heard. Repetition can make a claim feel truer without making it true.
  3. Pick one deep source. Choose one book or long read for the month, and plan to finish it.
  4. Add one source you can check. Look for someone with a track record you can check, or who loses something when wrong. Neither proves them right, but both beat confidence.
  5. Review once a week. Ask which sources changed something you did or decided. Keep those, and trim the rest. This is our rule of thumb.

Goes with: Your mind is like your stomach (our framing) ↑

This week

This week: run the filter on three claims

Pick three claims you saw shared this week. Put each through the four questions, and write one line on what you found. Then note which ones you'd still share.

Goes with: A quick filter before you believe something ↑

Steps

Bring the other side into your decisions

  1. Hear it before you decide. Munger noted that people hold on to the first conclusion they reach. Hear the opposing case before yours sets.
  2. Ask someone to argue against you. Before a big choice at work or home, ask one person to make the strongest case for the other option.
  3. Write their case so they'd accept it. Show your version to someone who holds the view, and ask if they'd accept it.
  4. Answer the central point. Graham's ladder rates the form of a reply. Aim for the top rung, not a reply to tone or to the person.

Goes with: Watch your own bias, and find the strongest version of the other side ↑

Tools

Go further on this site

Goes with: Further reading ↑